Loved this top for an easy but chic look. Thick material was good for chilly weather. A bit tight, but in a way that made it even more slimming

I love it. Second time renting it and this time I bought it. It flares out a little at the hips so is sometimes hard to tuck in but I made it work. Love the flutter sleeves and the fabric is thick and stretchy and feels luxurious. Simple and beautiful.

I loved how thick the material was on this shirt. The structure was nice and the ruffles at the sleeve make it different. I would describe the neck as mock Turtleneck.

WFH power top! Loved wearing this, felt very chic on zoom. Professional and flattering. Also perfect for a night out. Can dress up or down. Like other reviews say, runs a little tight through arms and shoulders. Could've definitely sized up and would've been perfect.

Material is thick and of high quality. I wore it multiple times - with jeans for the weekend and with a pencil skirt for work. Not ideal for tucking into a skirt because of how thick the material is and the length (would have helped if it were longer), but I made it work because I wanted to wear it again before returning! Overall, a great top for winter. I could see how the arms may give some folks a problem - they were snug on me compared to the bodice, but not at all uncomfortable.

This shirt is amazing. So much so, that I'll be wearing it once more with pants before returning. If my arms were any larger, I would think the sleeves would be a little tight. It definitely required my fiancé to help me get the very long zipper up. It fit fine under a light jacket without flattening the ruffles upon removal.

Snug but comfortable fit with forgiving thick material. Lots of compliments.

Runs a little big in the waist but incredible pants that I really want to buy. I was stopped multiple times & the compliments didn't stop. They were too big though & slowly worked their way down as I walked!!! I just subtly slid them up from time to time!

I got a size too small and felt squeezed in- my fault not the shirt. Bells out at the bottom a little and not flat like the pictures make it look.

The fabric is very thick and not giving. A little difficult to get into because the zipper is long and tight but if you have help the top fits beautifully! It's on the longer side And a bigger along the waist so I believe it's supposed to be untouched however I wanted it tucked in with the skirt.

Loved! Only negative is it Fit really tight around arms

This turtleneck fit me to the tee!

The design of this top is amazing. I got tons of compliments and it can be styled many different ways. One thing to consider is the material is very thick. Almost like that of a scuba suit. You literally have to unzip it and climb into it like a scuba suit. It's a bee with an itch to zip up by yourself but since when has being beautiful been easy? If you have bigger biceps or forearms you might want to pass on this shirt as the sleeves are very snug.

As others have stated, 'scuba chic' is very fitting for this top. Chic it definitely is. I am here for just the right amount of drama on the sleeves. Due to being petite, however, the overall fit was a teeny awkward and long. Would definitely wear again, though. It's a staple!!

The overall look of this shirt is cute. But the sleeves fit really tight and the bottom of the shirt flared out. I wanted a full body fit. But I still liked the shirt.

As others have said, this shirt is tight and an odd material. I was going to send it back immediately but it actually works well with pants for work. I felt like a powerful scuba diver from a weird military group. I wouldn't buy but it's a fun out of the box shirt.

Fits tight overall, but, looked well made/structured. Hard to zip up without help.

Fits like a bodysuit. Super tight very uncomfortable

Fits true to size, Color easy to match!!

So many compliments. Great fit. Statement piece but not too flashy.

Loved this shirt, could work with a number of different outfits, really comfortable and elegant.

This is a really unique, flattering and high-quality top. The fabric is nice and thick, which makes it look really polished. Yes, it's tight but it has a lot of stretch. I'm typically a 4/6 and the medium was perfect. The flutter sleeves make your arms look thinner and also give the illusion of smaller waist/bust and balance out your hips (if you have wider hips). I loved this top - it goes with anything. If you are not into statement shoulders though, you might not like it.

The fit of this shirt was incredible and super comfortable. Even with a larger chest, I found the length was perfect and it wasn't boxy at all. Only challenge was zipping it alone as it zips all the way up the neck from the mid back. Definitely considering purchasing it.

Fitted, thick fabric. Felt very beautiful in it and got lots of compliments.

The fit was perfect! The fabric is pretty thick and has a nice feel which kept the capped sleeve open.

Great fit

Great winter piece. I work in a design firm in NYC and I wore this many times. Warm, comfy and edgy.

This is one of my favorite rentals! I am typically a size 4 and the medium fit perfectly. It's a classic deep black mock turtleneck with a twist. The ruffles are somehow edgy and very modern, not overly girly. The material is heavy and substantial with some stretch, and is very flattering. I agree with other reviewers that it can be difficult to zip or unzip. Would love to rent this again!

The material is a little tight on the arms, but overall I felt like a fashionista with this shirt.

It was very nice, thick but stretchy fabric.

The top was really fitted, so it was a little tight but there's enough stretch that makes it comfy!

I love the material on this top, it is thick and warm and durable all while looking chic and sophisticated. I wore this to work and it truly dresses up any outfit.

My office is thankfully freezing cold-otherwise i would have been way too hot in this. The fabric is quite thick and the fact that you are zipped all the way to the neck makes it very insulating. Lots of compliments and very classy.

Tight fitting (runs true to size but a touch on the snug side), Zips up in back so may be helpful to have someone to help zip you. Overall great update on basic black top.

Very cute and flattering. Could have gotten away with a smaller size bc it was too long and thick to tuck in.