I love this shirt! It's so unique. The 'scarf' part doesn't always stay put but that's part of the charm. It really elevated my everyday wear. I paired it with a high waisted proenza schouler pants also on rtr.

This shirt sparked a lengthy discussion among my colleagues at a work meeting, because people thought it was interesting, but couldn't make sense of the 'right' way to wear it, either. It's a little bulky and large. It was warm and cozy and kind of interesting, but I am not sorry it's not in my permanent closet.

I was pleasantly surprised by this top. It is a nicer version of sweatshirt type material, but with more structure and interesting lines. Depending on how you wrap the sweater, it felt a little like wearing a scarf around your neck.

I loved this sweater! The neck scarf detail was unique and I got tons of compliments. It was surprisingly warm and was a good sweater to wear under my coat during Chicago's Polar Vortex! Sleeves were a tiny but long for me but I just rolled them up and it worked fine. Wore it twice!

All good - liked fabric, weight, and style. Perfect length for jeans or skinny pants.

I love this. It is more of a heavy shirt material than a sweater which I like because I find wool to be too itchy. It is warm and very soft. It fits a little boxy and I might have been able to wear a small but it isn't too big to wear. I wore it with jeans but slim fit black pants would work as well. I would buy it if I could afford it.

Loved this sweater for thanksgiving weekend. Perfect for a cold day walking about and loved the attached scarf.

Very nice for a nice dinner

I would have worn it more if I had the M. L was too big and looked like it

awesome. nearly bought it. decently warm

I couldn't believe how many compliments I got. It was so great! It was comfortable and classy!

I was surprised at how soft and comfortable this sweater was! The scarf was a little tricky to figure out, and required constant adjustment throughout the day, but I received so many compliments and had a few family members pick up the scarf and try to figure out if it was attached :)

It's a sweater with an attached scarf. Not bad but not thrilling either. The fit is boxy, the sleeves were plenty long enough and the scarf is the only interesting thing about the sweater.

Very comfortable and I received many compliments; however, it was a little big so I might try it again in a small, as I am considering buying the item. I can see myself wearing it often.

Sturdy and warm but it's huge!

I liked this sweater, but it was strangely long in the torso. The fabric is really too thick to tuck in, so I think it works best if you have a slim, athletic build.

Sweathshirt like material, but with style. I may try this again in a smaller size.

#perfectfallsweater

too boxy of a fit but like the neck wrap detail

I should have rented the medium; large was a bit too big. Very warm and cozy sweatshirt material. Fine for a casual weekend look.

Fit was great, scarf had to be readjusted several times during the day. Not a huge issue but depending on where you wore the shirt, could be.

I didn't realize how heavy the fabric for this top would be and because the scarf uses the same fabric, it makes it very stiff and unwieldy to wear. I can see why other reviewers didn't like the fact that the scarf fell off the shoulder easily. I didn't end up wearing this top because there's no way I can keep fiddling with the scarf while running after two kids all day!

This looked so cute on the model. But I had a ton of trouble trying to get the scarf to lay flat. I didn't realize until I got it that you have to wrap it yourself. It sticks up weird around the collar or wraps your arm tightly at your side. Maybe there's a way to do it but I didn't figure it out. Ended up wearing on a trip but only very briefly. Disappointed in this one.

I did not actually wear out. It was too big and just looked sloppy. I would say size down if you are daring enough to try to pull it off.

Frumpy! The scarf top bothered me!!!!