Love!

Definitely size down! I'm 5'8 closer to 140 these days. Most of my jeans are size 27 or 28 (4/6) and I ordered the 2/26 and they fit perfectly!! These aren't the super high wasted ones and the hit about an inch or 2 below my belly button (I have a short torso). They are comfy too! Going to be buying Good American jeans this Fall!

I had been wanting to try Good American jeans since I hear they have a lot of stretch and no waist gap for folks with hips and bottoms. They did not disappoint! The stretch is great and I usually buy a tall in jeans and these regular length ones fit great!

Size down for sure! These are beautiful; I'll definitely be renting other Good American jeans from RTR!

Upon arrival these looked small. Like so tiny I almost didn't try them on, but so glad I did! They are more like jegging material so they stretch, in a good way, in all the right places. They're high waisted and hide any imperfections, no spanx needed. ;) I'm 5'9" and the length was perfect. I dressed these up with a blazer for a work luncheon and will definitely rent again.

A bit short but work well as ankle jeans! Definitely size down, I'm usually a 30 but the 30 was way too loose and the 29 was perfect. Great everyday jeans! (Mid rise)

These jeans were so comfy and stretchy but still true to form and not jegging type thin. I think I need to buy them. I could wear them everyday!

The color of these jeans are fantastic. Wore these all day to a festival - lots of walking, dancing and hanging out and they did not stretch out or get loose. They are perfectly form fitting to curves which is the best to eliminate the large waist gap issues that I always run into. I'm 5'4 and did roll the bottoms up one time. Great rental!

The top of the jeans hit right of my bellybutton. They are super comfortable, easy to move in and the washy very slimming. I normally wear a four or six and I got the 4R and still think that I should have sized down to a two

These ran a little big on me but I also don't have much of a butt. They made me look like I do, though!

These fit pretty well - I am between a 4 and 6 in pants with stretch and wore the 6. Not sure I would have wanted to go down to a 4 given how fitted the legs are. I have a very narrow waist and while there was no gapping with these, I would have liked a slightly closer fit given the amount of stretch. The rise was good and length was perfect on me at 5'5".

Based on reviews I sized down (would have normally gotten 4R, went with 2R). Glad I did because 2R was perfect. They did stretch out slightly by end of day but not much, and I don't think it was noticeable. I got these to wear with cropped tops and sweaters since they are high rise. They did the trick, but I would have actually gone even higher by an inch or so. Would rent again.

So comfy & made me feel super curvy! Literally the sweatpants of jeans!

stretchy, go smaller next time

Very comfortable but definitely size down!

They're quite a bit lighter in color than the photo but have good stretch and are comfortable. They were big in the waist for me.

Way too small, could barely get them on

Incredibly soft denim, super comfortable but these jeans were so big and too stretchy. Im not sure even a 00 would have fit properly.

Hugged every curve. Perfect jean. Had to buy.

I normally wear an 8 so being able to wear a 6 in these felt good. The quality of the denim is great. They had a stretch to them that made them very comfortable. I also liked the waistline of these. They gave me the coverage I desire around my tummy area.

This is one size larger than I usually wear and while I think my regular size could have helped to pull in my belly and still fit great, it might have been uncomfortable. This size was nice and tight in the thighs and butt, came up above my belly button and had a little bit of room in the belly area.

These bit like a glooooooooove for us big booty girls! I am 5'10 and the R was a tad short but manageable.

These jeans fit so well! They have stretch which is great. Comfy too. Love them.

I wanted to try these before buying them and I LOVE them!

I wore these several times. Impressed with Good American.

Love the midrise, stretch, and color. Works with any outfit, and I felt very stylish. Still debating whether to just buy them.

Love these jeans so much I ended up buying them. They hold in all the right places yet are so comfortable. Great jeans!

I was pleasantly surprised at how much I loved these jeans. They fit like a glove and were super soft. My only slight criticism is that this dark denim wash rubbed off on my hands and backpack after some wear. I'll definitely be renting more Good American from now on.

Didn't love the color but fit was good.

I rented these because I wanted to try them out before I committed to buy and let me tell you I am convinced I will be buying them the fit was perfect they are of a stretchy material and a good quality and there is no gap in back

Seriously the best for curvy people. But they run big. I will order a new pair in a smaller size. Perfect for work, date night, brunch, and just about every other occasion.

So comfy and fits curvy girls

These jeans had a comfortable fit, and were true to size.

I love this brand ; however, I needed a 2 in this style. I texted a 4 in the frayed bottom so I thought the fit would be the same. Take away - these jeans are the best brand I've ever worn. You will love them!

These jeans are the best fit that I've found. They have a little stretch, but don't get baggy or loose after wearing them for a while. They're so comfortable and stay looking good all night! I may buy these.

Wore them for a full day meeting and had no annoying issues where jeans can shift or the fit was off. Very soft and comfortable

Good American jeans look awesome on every body type! I love them.

Love the high waist, very comfortable jeans. Nice color too

These jeans were fantastic! Like other reviews they do run a little large, I normally wear a 26 and these were a 25 so definitely size down! Overall great jeans very soft, I will definitely order some!