This sweater is really flattering and comfortable. It fits true to size and the buttons on the sleeves are a cool detail.

I ended up not wearing this because there was a missing button and a patched up hole that was noticeable. But the sweater itself is great. The bare shoulders, buttons down the side, and shape was super fun. It was a little baggy but totally worked with skinny jeans. I REALLY like the cut. The weight of the material helped with the shape. I don't like it when I look/feel like a balloon in baggy clothing- this hugged my boobs well but was still comfy around the stomach.

Fit well, true to size. I didnt realize it was cold shoulder when I ordered it. The cold shoulder kind of fell on a weird part of my shoulder, like more towards the back. Otherwise a nice sweater but not blown away.

I agree with many other reviews: the cotton is not soft and you should probably size up. But I think the shape would be very flattering on many body types. Somehow it's relaxed yet structured. One thing to note, it has cold shoulders and buttons all the way down the sleeves... Which I wasn't expecting. But if you look at the RTR model pics it's pretty obvious.

I love the fit of the torso (this part is very flattering!), but I hate the shoulders and sleeves. The shoulder gap (peep holes?) are pretty big and the fabric bunches because the seams are rolled. The sleeves are pretty baggy in comparison with the rest of the sweater, so it bunches strangely (particularly in the armpits, there's some bubbling going on. Not a fan.

Rented because I was in mourning and did not want to buy any more black clothing. The whole shipment was a waste. Form too too big. I did not wear it at all.

Great sweater for prego ladies who want to show off their bump

I enjoyed wearing this sweater quite a bit. It's such a nice knit with the button sleeve detail with just a bit of the shoulder showing. The M was a touch too big; should've gotten a small.

Light weight and breathable sweater.

Warm and good quality

I wore this to work and received a few compliments. My only complaint was that it was not a warm sweater. My office is very cold and it didn't keep me warm.

Wore once with jeans. Felt cute and was as expected.

Liked the fit of this sweater, would have liked it to be a little longer.

Kind of boxy and the arms where shorter that I would have liked.

I wanted to love this sweater. I love the pattern and its such a classic look. I didn't enjoy the side details with the large buttons. Also, the sweater mimics the cold shoulder trend which I'm not a big fan of.

Scratchy material, short for a sweater

This sweater has a rich feel and unique look with still a casual feel.

It runs in the smaller size. I usually wear a large. I ordered an xl because I like sweaters bigger. I wore the sweater with a tank to make sure my belly was covered. I did really loke the detail. The buttons thay run down the sleeves were cute. The key holes in the shoulders were an extra detail. And the sides have slits. So all in all if I were thinner I would probably love it.

I wanted to love this but the shoulders and arms were way too big/long.

Hard to tell on picture but there are buttons on the side of sleeves and a small cold should slit. The sleeve length was a bit awkward, like you have to push them up a bit.

The sweater was too short to fit over my pregnant belly, I am currently 34 weeks. This is also a "cold shoulder" sweater with holes in the shoulder area I didn't notice in the pictures

Fits nicely, cute but not that exciting.

Cute style with buttons on the sleeve. Sleeves are slightly bulky and I received this piece with a small tear on the cuff

I like soft sweaters. This is not a soft, comfy sweater. The material is cotton, but it’s rougher than expected. I didn’t know it had the shoulder cutouts. I’m not a fan of that look.

The sweater i was sent is missing a button on the left sleeve. The buttons/open shoulder were not clear to me when browsing/selecting. Could be cute if in good shape.

I didn't realize this had buttons down the sleeves which I do not like.

This sweater has open shoulders in addition to the slits at the sides. Not exactly the look I was going for with a winter sweater. Returned without wearing.

it had peak a boo arms all the way down, which did not show through on the pictures. arms were huge and unflattering.