I absolutely loved this sweater and I was very tempted to keep it. I love the stripes and it is so cozy and comfortable. I rented the S and it worked fine even though I'm usually a M. I think because of the flowy style the sizing is pretty flexible.

Looks great with dark jeans and the drape is a fun change for the winter.

I ordered this for everyday wear as winter transitions to spring. Great piece and I may just have to keep it. Sweater is thicker but not too winter thanks to the cotton blend. Definitely runs a little larger so size down. I'm 24 wks pregnant and wore a small (my usual size but I usually wear a Medium when pregnant). The jeans in the pic are also RTR (J brand maternity size 27).

I wore this sweater on a very cold day and was kept perfectly warm all day. The drape in the front of the sweater was long enough to wrap around me, but not bulky or heavy. I'm 5'3" so the length was fairly long and hit me below the knees. The material was soft and not itchy at all.

This cardigan made an otherwise boring outfit super cute! It was also really comfortable and fit true to size.

I absolutely loved this sweater. Comfortable and cozy yet didn't add weight or look bulky. Easy to dress up or down, I wore to work and also to parties on the weekend.

Very cute and cozy sweater. Easy to wear. Loved the length

I put the colors in the title so that you don't miss it's navy, not black. It's comfy and I always size down in cardigans because of the large amount of material. I'm normally a S or XS and chose the XS. Glad I did.

Totally my bad - I didn't read the reviews that specified that this is actually navy and tan, not black. It was dark and rainy when I got dressed and I paired it with black leggings, only to realize when I got to my brightly lit office that it was black! Oops! :) It's really long - I'm 5'3 and it fell well below my knees, so heads up for the short girls!

Loved this sweater so much I want to buy and keep forever so I can where it whenever I want. I wore with leggings and riding boots to casual Friday at work. Fits great. Not too big or too small. Length is perfect even if you are short. Very warm and cozy on a cold winter day.

Loved it so much I bought it instead of sending back!

Note: It is navy! Great sweater though. Thick, quality fabric. Lots of compliments and great for fall/winter. Would rent again.

Cute sweater. It was plenty warm enough for Southern California fall nights. The sleeves were just long enough for me, which is a big surprise in a size small. I am about 5'10" and have long arms, and they came exactly to my wrist. I would rent again

Loved it! Great for casual or can dress it up!

Super cute. Goes well with any attire (jeans, work pants)

I usually wear M in tops but the S fit my shoulders and arms well. Love this cardigan- got compliments at work. Paired beautifully with lighter color tops but looked good on darker tops as well. I usually wore it with jeans or pants. I am 5'3 and it hit my back of my knee

The fit was perfect on this sweater, I wore it with a dress underneath and got tons of compliments.

This was one of the best sweater rentals to date. I was worried about the 'stripy-ness' of it all, but it was a winner. Warm but not too warm, flattering, and easy to wear with anything. It's navy but goes great with black.

Great open cardigan. So comfortable I wore it all weekend.

Soft and classic cardigan. Runs slightly big.

Loved it. Bought it. Can wear anywhere & with anything. Using constantly. Looks like the picture. Very flattering.

Love this sweater! It is a great light weight. Previous reviews mention that it's not black as it appears in the pics. This is true, but it is a VERY dark navy blue. This made choosing which top to wear under a little tricky. I ended up going with black, since my navy top was a stark contrast.

Beautiful and comfortable cardigan. Very flattering with a pair of skinny jeans and booties. Received several compliments. Definitely size down.

I usually wear a medium but I got a small in this because I figured it would be a little big. It fit beautifully and hugged in all the right places. The front also flows very nicely for a cardigan.

This is a great sweater. What you see is what you get with it! I would definitely rent again. The small (my normal size) fit fine, but I also could have gone down a size.

I loved wearing this to work over a blouse with dark blue jeans and boots; felt cozy but not sloppy with the sharp graphics, and I liked that it was navy not black. This is a sweater that works both for the office and weekend/casual dress.

I wore this sweater all through the holidays. Fit was a little big on me, but that allowed me to wear it over long-sleeve tops.

The color is Navy not black but looks great with jeans

Was a good weekend piece but the dark stripes are blue and not black. While I thought this was rather plain, surprisingly I got a few compliments on it!

I'm also tall, and the length worked well even with heeled boots.

I don't know what it was about these stripes, but they were super flattering!

This is a great everyday piece, goes well with many outfits. I'm 5'9" and was still long enough to cover my butt, so would feel comfortable wearing with leggings. Typically a size 4 top, and small fit me perfectly.

I'm usually a small but got an xsmall since I'm short and it worked out fine. It's NAVY not black ladies!

Fit perfectly as expected. Softest material ever!

Super comfy! Fit great and was the perfect sweater to dress up with a pair of jeans and booties or dress down with a good pair of leggings. Great to travel in!

This cardigan was true to size and perfect for daytime / work to evening wear. I consider purchasing it because its perfect!

Really nice and comfortable.

The sweater is lightweight but surprisingly warm when layered with a long-sleeve white t. It looks black in the picture but the stripes are navy & beige! I'm thinking about buying. It's a great length for tall girls- I'm 5'9" and the small was still perfect in the arms and back.

Great fitting!

Got this to wear over summer dresses in overly air conditioned offices. It was perfect, worm several times.