I ordered a large. I don't know that it runs small or if it is supposed to be form fitting. I would rather wear something looser, so I think the large was perfect for me. I plan on looking for this to buy. I get compliments when I wear it out. I love it! I love the layered look and I love that it is long enough to cover my back when I sit.

I really love this top. I thought it would be too big on my torso when I saw it on the hanger, but it ended up fitting just right. It was great to lounge in on the weekend. Thumb skits were a super cute detail.

This top was perfect for a casual-cute look. I wore it to a basketball game and drinks after. I loved the finger holes in the sleeves as well as the loose turtle neck. I hate tight things on my neck but this was cozy and not irritating like some. I looked put together but not like i was trying too hard.

Came with tags on! Ordered XS because Free People tends to run large. This fit me well and it is really long in the sleeves which works fine with thumb hose. Thought it was very flattering and lightweight material so I wore a tank top underneath. I rarely wear RTR things more than once, but I wore this twice prior to returning. One time was even on the airplane, so you can see how comfortable it is. Highly recommend.

I rented this for going on a long weekend in Dallas with a friend. The top I received was new with tags, which was a bonus. I normally wear a small in tops, but I rented a medium as sometimes Free People can run small. I'm sure the small would have been fine. I think the medium was a little baggy on me- the small may be more flattering. Anyway, really cute top for everyday.

This top is so simple and casual, but I love it!! its super stretchy, soft, and comfortable. Run your errands and hang with friends comfortably with this top on. I also love the thumb hole in the sleeve. This is a must have!

I love this top. The fabric is so soft and was easy to layer with a leather jacket. Love the thumb holes in the sleeves. Perfect for the transition into fall and winter.

Casual

So comfy and easy to wear. I bought it and have worn it almost every weekend since.

I loved this shirt. So cute, casual, and comfy

Perfect for a low key day! Light weight and comfortable. Extra bonus is the thumb hole sleeves!

Perfect fit. Flattering all over and super comfy

comfy

I absolutely loved this shirt! There was plenty of room in the small, which I guess is appropriate for this style (I usually prefer stuff that's decently fitted). It's light, super comfortable, and really cute on, and the thumb-holes in the sleeves are a nice extra.

I really like the sleeves on this shirt. Starting to look just a bit worn but still great for everyday.

The fabric is really thin but it is really cozy and a great casual top.

Very very cute and casual. I loved it.

This is a comfy shirt, great length. Wore it on the weekend to a child's birthday party. Cuter in person.

Such a comfortable top. Very stylish and easy to wear for afternoon errands.

cute

This was a nice shirt to wear for hanging out on the weekend. Love the thumb holes. It's a pretty thin material since the double layer is an illusion, so I wore an additional layer underneath.

Fit great, the sleeves are very long and the thumb holes are a cut touch. Great Fall turtleneck however it is Lightweight.

So soft and comfortable. I just loved it! The sleeves are super long, with thumb holes. Great weekend shirt!!

I enjoyed wearing this and considered buying it but since it already looked pretty worn on the sleeves I worried I would totally ruin it within a few wears. Also the sleeves were way to long in me but I liked them rolled up and it looked really cuter under sweaters or jackets.

I love the style of this top, and have worn it quite a few times in the last few weeks. But, its quality is far lower than other pieces I've rented. I'm not sure if it is just really well worn or an intentional "vintage" style but it looks beat up.

Runs a little big, consistent with Free People

The perfect everyday shirt. Not very warm but loved the long arms with thumb holes.

long sleeve is a thermal and the tee is a soft tee.

A casual knit top elevated with the layered look.

Order a size down. Rented the large and bought a medium on ebay because it's such a great shirt. Comfortable and cute. Worn with a black jacket and jeans. Several complaints about thermal portion being faded, however this is simply the fabric wash. I purchased a new one with tags and it comes this way. It is meant to look well worn.

I liked the thumb holes. Very snuggly to wear without any bulk.

The style was great and exactly what i need for winter time in Dallas. But I found it kinda wear out, the blue stained the whites. Overall ok

Thought it was more of a sweater type top but its t-shirt material - super cute & cozy

There really wasn't anything wrong with it, it just wasn't my style. I'm typically a size M and I got the L and it fit. I didn't realize the turtleneck was a ribbed material, I thought it was more of a finer gauge. Again, nothing really wrong with it, just not special.

The sleeves are very long and the neck was large. It was ok for something different but not great.

Would be a cute weekend staple, but probably not worth rent as far as wow factor.

It's a loose, baggy fit. Wish it were more defined around the waist.

It's a cute layered shirt, but it fits a little weird in the shoulders. Only Free People can take a concept so basic and somehow make it uncomfortable... Anyone who has worn the brand before will know what I'm talking about...