Wore this for "Crab Night" dinner event with friends. Felt perfectly cozy and theme-dressed (for my own amusement and comfort) like a New England fisherman!

I loved this! It was true to size and had a ski lodge feel. Thick and heavy. It did kind of lose shape as the night wore on, but still looked nice!

Want want want It's such a thick cable, soft and great to wear

Fun cold shoulder, great heavyweight material

Great sweater! Very comfortable but the cold shoulders dressed it up nicely. Great for work then going out afterwards. Wish I owned it!

I would say to go down a size. This was the perfect sweater for my girls night out!

Fits great for a 2nd trimester bump! I sized up one size from my regular (from a small to a medium).

So cozy, perfectly oversized, the cold shoulders jazz it up the perfect amount. I wore it 3 times in a week and loved it so much I bought it!

This sweater is beautifully made. The cutouts aren't weird or ill-fitting. It is the perfect balance between loose and fitted. If you have a straight and narrow body type, you can pair this with leggings. If you a curvier gal like myself, jeans would be best. Perfect spring transition piece!

This is obviously designed to be an oversized sweater, but due to its very thick stiff material it puffs or balloons up even more then it has to. It's not a soft cozy material, but it gives off the cute, cozy oversized look that you might be going for. The good thing is the heavy material will probably hold up well to cleanings. It probably won't look as worn as other sweaters you may be looking to rent. It's the kind of sweater that is great in theory, but slightly lacking in execution. But if you want the look, I'd still go for it. I might not rent again and might opt for something that falls a bit nicer and is softer, but it was a very cute look.

Fits as expected - slightly ovesized (as expected). Soft fabric, not itchy. I wore it on a work trip (8 hours through the airport and sitting on the plane, then right to work training in a cold place). It was comfortable and easy to wear. I have a long torso, so i wish it were just a tad longer. One other con i found was that the bottom stretched out a little bit after hours of sitting and plane travel. The pro is that i didnt have to buy a bunch of cold weather sweaters for this trip, since i live in a tropical climate most of the year, this was awesome to travel with! #sweaterweather #travelswag #workflow

This sweater is super comfy - but is really bulky fabric and it's very form-fitting, so I felt 'big' in it all day long. The sleeves are really cute - too bad it didn't look better. It runs bigs. I wore a Small, but normally would wear a Medium (or 6-8)

This was a good sweater to mix in to my winter routine. It did stretch through out the day. (I wore it to work and then straight to dinner.) It was a good rental piece.

I really liked the cream color and body fit of the sweater. Unfortunately it runs large in the arms which makes it look awkward, especially because there are cut out shoulders. Poor design. Would likely not rent again.

This was made of very thick material and looked really cute with a dark pair of jeans and some booties.

I️ rented this sweater to mix up my fall wardrobe a bit and I️ fell in love. It's so comfortable and warm. I️ read reviews that it was big and to size down. I️ wouldn't say the sweater runs big but it does stretch out as you wear it.

Very cute, comfy sweater. Wore this on a rainy weekend and didn't really need a jacket. Paired with black leggings and boots. Perfect for a lunch and early dinner date. Works for any bust size and is very true to size overall.

The arms were a little long for me, so I folded them at the cuff. This is more of a "cold arm" sweater than cold shoulder because my shoulders were covered, but it reveals the upper arm. Small fit me well without being tight and was a good length at the waist. You can wear a regular bra without it showing. Would rent again.

This item actually arrived with the tags still on. We planned an April trip to D.C., where weather is normally in the upper 70's-low 80's, during a surprise cold snap. RTR saved the day. I wore this cute cream sweater underneath a trench on a blustery, 48 degree day, paired with jeans and sneakers. I like my sweaters to fit oversized and cozy--which the Medium did. Came about mid thigh and covered my tush. Would definitely rent again.

SO COMFORTABLE. I loved the cold shoulder on this sweater because it made the warm knit a little cooler for a moderate fall-temperature day. It was so soft and comfortable, but it was a little big. I typically wear a size 10 in dresses, but the size Medium was even a little big. I probably still would have gotten the Medium though because I like the big comfy sweater look. This sweater is the perfect way to dress comfortably, but still look cute!

Love this oversized sweater. Wore it for thanksgiving and it was perfect and comfy

Very cute chill date night top. Fit true to size but I prefer my sweaters running a little bigger. Would size up for a oversized look. Keep in mind that sweater is heavy.

This was a nice sweater, very versatile. The fit was good, though if you want it more fitted go one size down, it was definitely roomy. Looks good with skinny jeans.

Loved this sweater. I wore it several times out before returning it.

Very cute sweater. Wore to a holiday open house and got lots of compliments!

I liked this sweater and got a lot of compliments on it, but because my arms are so short the holes felt like they took up half of my arm. I think it was just an awkward length for me.

I wish it was a little baggier but I loved wearing it.

As others have mentioned, this is a cold arm sweater, not cold shoulder. The fit is tts, bordering on generous. The sweater I received was very soft and comfortable. It looked great paired with black skinny pants and red Chuck Taylors.

It was stylish and cute on the hanger but slightly uncomfortable to wear because it felt stiff and bulky

Pretty sweater and very cute cold shoulder cut outs. However, I was not the biggest fan of how it looked on me. Regardless of that, I did wear it multiple times because it was easy to throw on and very comfortable.

Odd shaped cold shoulder

it was dry cleaned too much

The cut was fine (waist and chest were sized right) but it hit me at mid hip. With all of the bulk, no drape, and stopping right at the biggest part of my hip, it was not flattering. So disappointing!

I don't know if it was the fit or the fabric but this sweater made me look huge! Very bulky and hit right below the waistline with a bit of a flared out bottom that accentuated the love handle area. Just a no.

This sweater was very very thick material and was extremely stiff. I don't know if it's from the dry cleaning or just the material, but it felt like I was wearing a coat of armor when I put it on. It had no movement and was extremely unflattering due to it not having any stretch or give in the material. Not at all what I expected. I did not end up wearing it after trying it on.

The sweater has a nice quality; however, it probably rented and washed too many times that it shrunk so much is like a kid size in small now. Sadly I can't even wear it once.

Fit was overall kind of boxy, I didn't care for it and returned it without wearing.

Very cute for weekends, except the fit on the arm holes was so large, I couldn't wear it with any bra! Even with a strapless, the holes were so baggy that you could see through the back on both sides. Definitely plan on wearing it with a tank or bandeau underneath!

Very bulky. Did not wear

The fit runs small and the material has no give.