I loved a lot about this: The material (it's a heavy knit--not like a normal sweater), the cut sleeves at the hands, and the little hole details. Size up unless you want it to be very tight.

I like this type of knit, its very heavy, not soft thread ( items like that keep its form & don't wrinkle ), they are feels colder - not your cozy sweater, & have more weight), would be great with white jeans, i will re rent

It looked great and was fun to wear a blue during the winter instead of the normal black. I loved how it fit and I paired it with red lips and jeans.

I really liked this top. As everyone said, it's not very sweater-y - it's more of a tight, stretchy material. There are little holes on the stripes, which means a tank is required and also, I was very cold. I definitely couldn't have sized down, but for the most part I didn't find it overly tight, though it was a bit snug at the biceps.

Thought it was a sweater from the model pic but it's actually more of a thick stretchy material. It's a little loose through the stomach and then the waist band is tighter which I liked.

This isn't like a comfy, roomy sweater, as you would think from the photos. It's made of a thick elastic material that fits tightly. I didn't hate it - I still wore it to work - but I wouldn't rent again. It was tighter and less flattering than I would have liked. Also it wasn't a comfortable wear - I found the material kind of itchy.

I think this shirt is so cute but I'm somewhere in between the small and medium sizes. Per other reviews, this is not a sweater. The medium was big and baggy on me so I tried the small (pictured). The arms are squeezing my biceps and I have pretty thin arms. Also the elastic bottom of the shirt tends to ride up in an unflattering way. I still think it's cute it just didn't work for me as well as I wanted it to.

A bit short and tight, but expected since the large was noted as 8-10. What wasn't expected were the holes in the white stripes of the material. You have to wear a tank under it or else see bra/skin through the holes. I liked the ribbed material and the split cuffs, but didn't love the top overall. One wear was enough for me.

Incredibly stiff material and ran very small. I'm almost always a small or medium, and I could barely get this on. The stiff material made it even more difficult. Didn't wear.

Beautiful sweater with great details and fabric. One note though: the white dots in the picture are actually holes so if you're wearing this to work, you actually need a tank top underneath.

The sleeves are loose and they open up at the wrists which is cool.

The fit was great, roomy but not too big. So soft and comfortable. I got a lot of compliments on it.

Love this sweater fab weight, shorter on the body but worked with High waisted pants

Well made and great cut

It looked dressier than I expected and was very comfortable to wear. Those are not just white stripes, but rather an eyelet-like strip. It's navy not black but works either way.

A well structured, great styled piece for the office. Easy to wear alone. Very stylish sleeves and lines. Color deceiving, clearly navy.

Wore with white jeans to a casual office. Material feels very high end, and while the white stripe design includes small holes that you can technically see through, you don't need to wear a shirt under it.

the sleeves are a little annoying when you try to eat

Loved the fabric (silky stretchy), the fit, and the style. Fit tiny bit tight but not by much (I usually go bigger to be comfortable). Matches everything, good spice with nothing crazy. Splurged and bought it.

Was short, had to wear high waisted jeans. But super comfy and got compliments.

Ended up going with a different shirt (love walking into a RTR store, grabbing some options, and deciding later!) - but will rent this again.

Fits tight so take one size up your regular size

The fit was surprising but good. It accentuated the breast area and waist nicely but that wasn't what I expected.

I got a lot of compliments on this sweater. I thought it was studded but they were actually holes. Not a sweater for warmth.

This was cute, but pretty scratchy. It's kind of a hard, thin knit - not very warm.

I thought the material was going to be more sweater-like. It is made of thick, stretchy material. I liked that the arms were long enough for me. It is a little short at the waist, so I had to layer it with a white t-shirt underneath.

Great thin top. Not a sweater. lots of compliments. Loose fitting with tighter waist, cute cuffs

Great for everyday work. Received compliments. Navy, not black.

Loved the fabric and overall look, it just ran very small/tight for me.

It wasn't the most flattering sweater, in my opinion, I loved the sleeves, I thought the slit made them really unique but I wasn't a fan of the material. Also, when I rented I thought it was black but its actually a dark navy.

Pretty, simple piece.

Fabric was stiff and itchy

cute sweater. not cozy, but cute style.

This sweater is more of a shirt that doesn't fit right. The bottom is right and the rest of the shirt is pretty loose making it an awkward fit

Pros - the quality is strong and fit could be flattering Cons - Did not fit. I ordered in my normal Medium and I could barely get it on. I would need to size up 2 sizes for this to fit.

I didn't notice the cuffs on the sleeves are split and just kinda flop around. It ran a little full in the body and then the bottom cuff was tight, making this look sloppy. Seemed cute, but ultimately I didn't wear it.

Agree with the other reviewers- material is weird! Was actually really scratchy (I have really sensitive skin) so I didn't even wear it. It's a little short too. If the material hadn't been uncomfortable, I probably would have worn once and sent back. Would have been cute otherwise.

This fit very strangely - I ended up not wearing it