Ended up wearing this with a skinny leg pant and some booties. Great fit!

Love the slight ruffle detail on the sleeve and the high/low hemline. Worked great with either leggings or skinny jeans.

It runs a little large but perfect for the comfortable fit I was looking for. Looks great with leggings and boots and is very warm even though the sleeves are short.

Wore over a tissue t- neck for a date with my husband. He complemented the look. I was ver comfortable and felt like I looked contemporary.

Shorter than I expected, have to wear with pants rather than tights.

For reference, I am 5'8 and this ran a little short from me. But a pair of opaque tights underneath did the trick. The material is thick but a little itchy in places where it rubs your skin (armpits). Great, casual dress. Could definitely be dressed up with accessories and boots.

It's not that it was ugly, but the sleeves were a little weird and unflattering. Did not have any shape to the rest of the dress.

This was way too big. Just sort of hung on me and looked frumpy. I never wore.

Wore this with distressed jeans and flat sandals on a spring day and it was perfect! Not too hot and didn't need a jacket. Perfect chill spring weekend outfit.

I wore this over jeans with booties so many times. I don't do great with wool, so by the end of each wearing I was miserable with itching, but it was just so cute!

Had rented in grey. Loved this in black even more. Weight of knit and quality of construction are excellent. It really holds its shape. Wore with leggings and tall boots.

Love how comfortable yet stylish this piece was. I will probably rent it again.

Comfortable, stylish and drapes nice!

Fit was a little big but the dress was very comfortable. It was a little short (I am 5/2) so taller people may want to keep that in mind. I wore mine with black tights.

The fit is great and it looks good dressed down for work or dressed up for going out.

Heavy cotton sweater that drapes really nicely over leggings. Covers the bum. A bit oversized, which I loved.

Love this. Great for work or casual. Can dress up or down. AND its super comfortable. If only it had pockets... sigh

Great fit and not too huge....although it fits loose.

Loved it. Easy and flattering

This was adorable and not shapeless like so many sweater dresses. I am 5'5 and definitely needed tights underneath due to the length. It went well with tall boots and a leather jacket from work to dinner on a cooler fall evening. Would definitely recommend.

Super comfortable and wears well over leggings as we move into Spring.

This top is definitely a top and not a dress! With that said, it's great for leggings as it comes to your mid to high thigh. I wore it twice - once to work and once on the weekend and really liked both looks. The only downside is that it picks up lint and hair VERY easily.

Runs large Easy to dress up or down

Loved this sweater. It was even warm enough for the Buffalo winter! A bit large but not uncomfortably so. Paired well with leggings and boots for work, and jeans and edgy sneakers for a dinner date. The only problem I had was there was a tiny hole when I received the sweater which opened a bit upon wearing. Otherwise, great winter piece.

I wished it was a bit smaller. The split on the sides are higher than expected, but when I wore it with a little thick leggings, I liked it.

fit fine. Just black, boxy sweater, but it didn't feel like anything special.

Looks a little dowdy

Didn't wear it because it was so big in the shoulders, even at 7 months pregnant. I think the style is intentional but I looked like a linebacker in it!

This is more like a sweater than a sweater dress. To me, it seemed extra short from all the cleaning it's had. I don't think it was made that short, it has just steadily shrunk up. Too short to wear, even with opaque tights. I'm 5'6".

This sweater dress was just meh for me. I felt like it was too long in the back, making it look a little awkward. Even in the XS-S it seemed big and lacked shape.

I rented this for work but it ended up being too boxy and short barely covering my crotch. Overall just not a good fit

Just a little too baggy. An okay casual look but not my favorite.

This was really cute, i wore a couple of times pairing it with jeans or leggings and booties. It was flattering and concealed my baby bump (22 weeks). it it quite heavy tbh and probably better work when the weather is a bit cooler

I loved this sweater but I wish I would have sized down. I am usually a 12-14 but this sweater is huge, even to wear over leggings. It would have been much cuter had I gotten the m/l sweater instead of the l/xl. I do plan on renting again, though. It paired really well with Spanx leggings

So short

The length was too short for my heigh. It's like a long sweater. I don't want to wear it. Will return without wearing it.

Very heavy. Looked frumpy. Did not wear.