One of my favorite rentals. Cozy vibes while still looking chic. Wore this 3 times in one week. Absolutely loved it.

The knit was really chunky and so warm. The color of this sweater stands out so much! Sleeves are a little long.

Got so many compliments in this sweater. Kept me cute and warm while walking the St. Patrick's Day parade on a 29 degree day in NYC. Love the turtle neck and sleeves very high fashion. I'm usually a size 4 and an XS fit perfectly oversized.

Since this only comes in XS and M i went for the M! It was oversized which worked great for Christmas overeating! Great color for family photos as well!

Need to buy this sweater! Was quite oversized but perfect for a cold winter night. Sleeves and collar are large but not bulky and it is very cozy. Longer length so definitely size down if you are petite. Color was gorgeous !

Lovely color and definitely warm. Would say this sweater is a bit long for short folks, and the rolled sleeves make it hard to wear a jacket over, but it's perfect by itself on a crisp fall day.

This sweater is so soft and the chunky knit makes it very comfortable to wear all day. Like others have mentioned, it runs VERY large, so definitely size down. The color is a muted evergreen and is quite lovely. This will help keep you warm, but I wore a camisole underneath and I was comfortable indoors. When I went outside, I could feel the wind through the sweater. But overall, a nice sweater that is perfect for chilly weather.

Comfortable sweater. Pretty color (photo doesn't due it justice). Starting to pill a bit. Seemed like it had been worn a few times. Good for the day but wont rent again

Soft and comfy - the bell sleeves really are long but once you roll them up, they mostly stay put.

Size down. The sleeves can get in the way sometimes too. But I loved it so much I bought it!

material had nice shiny threads in it

THE ARMS ARE WAY TOO LONG!

Little bit oversized fit, which is perfect. Very comfortable.

This top was so so cozy and warm. I am someone who always runs cold so I am not afraid to be *too* hot. That's just not a thing in my world, especially when I was out in Chicago for the holidays! This was the perfect thing to wear while lounging around with family, watching football, and having snacks. Everyone loved the subtle metallic glimmer in the thread and the color was amazing and rich. I almost decided to buy it but figured that in sunny SoCal, it wouldn't get as much use as it deserves. Still dreaming of its warmth now that the weather has turned frosty for us...

The sleeves and neck are long like the photo shows, but the rest of the sweater isn't very oversized. Great feeling sweater, very nice. I rented it to pair with a short, sparkly dress as an experimental look and it was a perfect.

Definitely size down (at least 1 size). Normally I wear small in sweaters and the XS was still roomy. Sleeves are very long, and you can't really wear a coat over it because the sleeves don't fit, but the material and color is gorgeous. Wore to work and was literally sweating all day because of how warm the material is. Great sweater for outdoor activities or to pair with jeans.

The only con I found with this sweater was that it pilled by the second time I wore it. Otherwise I loved it!

Rented this for work. Lots of compliments, very warm and so pretty on!

Was really comfortable, nice color, loved it.

I absolutely loved this sweater. The color is gorgeous and I received many compliments. I would have bought it if it wasn't so expensive to keep. I wore it once to work and then once out Day drinking for St. Patrick's day celebration in Pittsburgh. Very warm and roomy. Other reviews complained that it was itchy, but I didn't think so at all. This sweater was perfect & I plan to rent it again!

obsessed with this elizabeth and james sweater. The quality was amazing and it came brand new w the tags on. Rented this through unlimited and kept it for about a week and a half wearing it as much as I could . The quality is great and the wool is super soft. Love the chunkiness of the knit--beware you will get hot in this so wear it with a lighter coat. would rent this again :)

I wore it with super tight black jeans and heels and I was in love. It's a loose fit but such a cute sweater

Beautiful shimmery metallic threading (green) that you cant see on the web photos.

Super cute chunky sweater. More emerald than forest green because of the sparkle in the knit. Fold in the sleeve is anchored with a stitch, so it can't be repositioned. I'm 5'1" so this meant the sleeve was long for me but there was not a lot I could do about it: they don't really push up. Length extended all the way around my hips also, and the chunkiness of the sweater made me look a little "hippy" as a result: I think it would look much cuter at a different length on a taller person with more breasts to balance that out. Even in size XS the proportion was just wrong for me.

I wore this for walking around town on a cold day and it was lovely. Super soft yarns and really warm. The style/sizing is quite chunky so it looks best with skinny jeans or leggings. I have this a 4 rather than a 5 because one sleeve had a quarter-size hole in it (not noticeable when worn).

As others have described, this is intentionally oversized. It was great for deep winter. The shiny thread is subtle and works well to dress it up a little. The cuffs didn't stay in place well but it didn't bother me. Got tons of complements- definitely eye catching for a sweater.

Sweater is great for winter, especially on the east cost. Color is really rich and more vibrant than the photos. Would rent again.

Loved wearing this as it was cozy and comfortable. The only issue is washing hands and handling items is a bit of a chore with this on! Definitely wear on a chill casual day, more of a weekend piece than work or everyday.

Great everyday sweater. I did not love the sleeves, but that did not stop me from wearing this warm sweater.

Sign of multiple wears was very apparent. It was already showing pilling.

Wore this for a casual movie date with friends. Super cold night and I was warm & comfy. It runs really large!!! I was looking specifically for green because of St. Patricks day & took a chance on ordering this in a medium because that was the largest size available. It had a nice relaxed roomy fit, the L or XL would've looked crazy on me and I usually rent a size 12 or 14 from RTR.

The sweater was very big for a petite gal. I was not expecting it to be fitted, but I did want something that I felt comfortable in. The cuffs came down almost to my fingertips, and there was an extra 6-8 inches in the waist.

I liked it! I didn't think it was too big or awkward, as someone said they wore it as a joke. Although I can see if you are short, this sweater will consume you ! This sweater piles up a lot! I can't imagine it lasting long for that price, but it was a happy addition that kept me warm with my unlimited membership.

Casual, big, roomy and very warm.

This is a great holiday sweater that sweater that still feels elegant. The metallic threads are more "glowy" than "sparkly" and are pretty subtle. It's very warm, soft, not itchy. The sleeves run kind of long but it didn't really bother me. I'll probably rent it again.

Oversized fit, but not too baggy. I was shocked at how long the sleeves were... I'm lanky and they went to my knuckles. Disappointed with the amount of pilling. I expected better quality for the price tag

the sleeves are definitely a lot bigger in person, almost awkward to even wear

This turtleneck was very warn and also had a flattering fit for something so bulky, but was mind of meh/nothing special.

the color is great and it's a very warm sweater, but the oversized fit and cuffs of the sleeves make it look a bit sloppy.

This sweater was cute and cozy with slim black pants for a chilly winter day in a casual office. My only complaint was that it was a bit scratchy, even with a tank top underneath. Not sure I would wear it again because of that.