Loved these jeans, would buy. High quality, comfortable. Wore every day of comic con

Great fit for straight to slightly curvy girls. Love Citizens. Fit true to size

Love these jeans! They're nice and thick and a little stiff but true to size for me. I usually wear a 28 in jeans with stretch but did a 29 in these. So flattering on the front lower belly area! I've had 3 kids and some jeans just don't look good on the lower mom belly but these smoothed and kept everything nice and flat! I'm 5'4" and thought the length was perfect with a boot

Fit was true to size, wash is more gray than black which I assume is due to lots of wears. High waist, quite slim through the leg with just a bit of a flare/straight cut at the calf. They really fit more like a skinny jean than a straight leg. Also quite short - I’m 5’6” and they could have been 3-4” longer and still fit ankle length/ not touching a shoe.

A little snug but they loosened up after a couple wears. Love how they look overall!

I'm not sure what it is exactly that makes these jeans so uncomfortable but I wish I would've passed on this rental. Firstly, I was stunned they even fit after reading the reviews of the odd fit/skinny legs. I ordered a size or two up from my normal size and they fit perfectly in the waist. Oddly enough, I think my torso is too long for them - they're uncomfortable when sitting and when standing. Definitely a pass and sending back asap.

Love these jeans. Kept them for multiple shipments! Wear them all the time. Dress up, dress down, they are great.

Considering buying these. Perfect length on my 5’3 frame, great color, and nice high rise. So glad I read the reviews first and sized up. Usually a 25/26 depending on the brand and amount of stretch but I went up to a 27 (no stretch) and they’re the perfect fit. Don’t think I’d have been able to get a 26 all the way up.

These jeans are so comfortable and the perfect everyday fit. I wore them several times without them stretching out.

Great fit and cut. Well made and couldn’t pass up the great price.

Love the color and cut of these jeans! They go with everything!

I sized up based on reviews and they have the true boyfriend fit. So comfy I could wear in the place of leggings- obsessed!!

These jeans fit as expected and were super flattering. Love them and will rent again.

I could live in these jeans. I've kept them for 3 months now and consider buying. Comfortable, I love the color which is very dark grey and goes with everything. True to size, they support well my belly in a flattering way. Maybe I love them so much because they remind me my favorite jeans I wore in 1990s.

A high quality denim. The button-up top held everything in and remained structured (no fold over at the waist). Hit my leg right above the ankle. Considered buying.

I rented these jeans and from the moment I first tried them I knew I needed to keep them. They are just really wonderful winter jeans. They keep you held in, are thicker/warmer, and perfect for my 5'3 frame. They cost a lot more than I usually spend on jeans but based on how much I have worn them, it is worth it!

These jeans were super cute and comfortable, but are definitely a little short for tall girls. They really were great though!

Great cut and perfect for an everyday Jean. Not super dark so they feel a little more casual.

Almost bought. Great fit.

Love these they fit perfect and are slimming alternative to skinny jeans.

Great fit, true to size

This is a true vintage-inspired fit with a flattering high-rise waist and straight leg silhouette. If you're hoping for a jean with a 90's vibe - this is it. The inseam is 28" long which is good to note for the petite renters - but overall a great way to tap into a new jean fit without feeling too trendy.

Super comfortable, great everyday pants

Super comfy, dress up or down

perfect length

Fit well and comfortable

Too small

A little too much give in the waist but overall a a great pair of jeans. Just the right length too.

These are so cute and high quality, but the fit was just not right for me. I usually wear a 10/30 in jeans and occasionally a 12/31 (32in waist, 42in hips). I sized up based on other reviews of this brand and they fit just right in the waist and butt, but were uncomfortably tight at the top of my thighs and they do not stretch much at all. I'm not sure sizing up another size would have been better because then it might've been big in the waist. However, I did wear them twice and lived with the discomfort because they were cute and I really liked the length and cut of the legs otherwise. I would recommend ordering your larger size or a size up from that perhaps if you have larger thighs.

Maybe I needed to size up but these are more of a skinny leg than a straight leg. Tighter on the calf than expected.

It was too short for someone 5'4'' which was odd.

Barely any room in the hips and butt. Couldn’t zip

great jeans, too small for me

Not very stretchy at all.

I'm always a 27 but these were way to small. couldn't wear.

I’m typically a size 27 in mother jeans and I got these jeans in a size 28 and they won’t even come close to buttoning. So size up!