This dress is a showstopper.
Little snug on the chest but not restrictive. No need for any spanx type undergarments due to excellent cut and quality. This dress is clearly loved and it was showing as it was looking worn. Maybe a handful of rentals left before it is unacceptable.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 12
LisaTop Contributor
Size 12
5' 7"
180 lbs
Hourglass
34DD
31 yrs
This dress is amazing!
Loved the look of this dress! It is a little snug in the hips, so not great for busting a move, but for an elegant event it is perfect!
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 6
FawneTop Contributor
Size 6
5' 3"
145 lbs
Hourglass
34B
37 yrs
Stunning in Silver!
Another RTR success! At 5'6" glad I went with the long so I could rock some 4" heels. Lots of compliments and very comfortable.
Size Worn: 8L
Usual Size: 8
RTR MemberTop Contributor
Size 8
5' 6"
145 lbs
Hourglass
36C
34 yrs
Silver perfect!
All the wedding party had to wear silver. No need to buy, just Rent!!! I ordered a 10 but sent it back for an 8 so it must run big. Needed some help with the zipper, but once in it was very comfortable. I felt beautiful in it. Such nice quality.
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 10
Dr. gwenTop Contributor
Size 10
5' 5"
140 lbs
Hourglass
36DD
70 yrs
Beautiful dress!
The dress is true to size. It was perfect for my work gala event. Everyone kept commenting on how lovely the dress was.
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 10
AshlieTop Contributor
Size 10
5' 5"
Full Bust
36DD
28 yrs
Suxh a comfortable, beautifully made dress! Received many compliments throughout the night .
Fit is true to size
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 10
MargaretTop Contributor
Size 10
5' 5"
128 lbs
Full Bust
36B
54 yrs
Awesome Experience!!! This was my first time using RTR. I wore it to my bonus Son's wedding.
The fit was perfect! I was worried about the top fitting as I'm a 36DDD. I actually went into the San Francisco RTR at Nieman Marcus to try on the dress before the event to make sure it fit. The staff at RTR were extremely nice and helpful. Back to the dress and the event- Ladies Be prepared to get it cleaned and pressed. When I received the dress it was very wrinkled and had a weird odor. Once had it cleaned and pressed - I put it on and was quite impressed. No problems in the bust area (I wore a regular bra - just tucked the bare shoulder bra strap under my bra. The length was great. It has a small train in the back - adding to the drama and elegance. I'm 5'4" and wore two inch heels. Finally, ladies be prepare to receive compliments all evening and say "Yes" to this Dress!!
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 10
KarenTop Contributor
Size 10
5' 4"
145 lbs
Full Bust
36DDD/E
61 yrs
Stunning Dress!
Pictures don't do justice to this elegant and extremely beautiful dress! I chose it for a black tie affair and it definitely stands out. The fit for me was a bit large on top so i had to use some fashion tape to prevent it from gapping. The size 4 would of been perfect on top but it didn't fit my hips well. I chose the long and it was right to the floor with 4inch heels. This dress is light and comfortable to wear, it moves with you and it hits in all the right spots to highlight the figure hiding any imperfections. Would highly recommend it!
Size Worn: 6L
Usual Size: 6
EuridiceTop Contributor
Size 6
5' 8"
118 lbs
Athletic
34B
51 yrs
Perfect for our Masquers Club Dance! True to size and i received so mamy complements!
Perfect dress, fit true to size. I thouht it was going to be heavy but it was lightweight ans easy to sit and dance in !
Size Worn: 6L
Usual Size: 6
MeaganTop Contributor
Size 6
5' 5"
138 lbs
Athletic
36C
29 yrs
It was a super fun night!
I loved this design! But I was a little disappointed because I read the reviews on how this was perfect for curvy girls like myself. I'm a little hippy so I thought it would have more room at the bottom, but it didn't. so I had to size up to a 14R. I normally wear between an 10/12 depending on the designer of course. But after I sized up it was perfect at the bottom! A little big at the top but nothing a few safety pins couldn't handle. I got tons of compliments and would definitely get this one again.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 14R
Usual Size: 12
QianaTop Contributor
Size 12
5' 5"
209 lbs
Pear
36D
42 yrs
Felt red carpet ready!
Despite NO time to actually "get ready" for this event, this gown made me feel like a star! I got Compliments all evening and for days after! Truly a show stopper! I did notice part way through the night that there was a separation at one of seams on the back of the dress (near my knees) which was disapointing but I doubt anyone saw. I'm 5'4 and 120 pounds for reference. It was snug across my (very full) hips/butt, not uncomfortable and did not prevente from moving/sitting. I was very happy with the way it fit because in some review photos it looked sloppy, and it was anything but sloppy on me.
Size Worn: 2R
Usual Size: 2
RTR MemberTop Contributor
Size 2
RTR overnighted me this dress because my first pick was delayed by UPS. This dress was perfect!
Fit like a glove. I was worried it might’ve been too long without heels, but it was just right
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 8L
Usual Size: 8
ShannonTop Contributor
Size 8
5' 7"
160 lbs
Hourglass
36C
31 yrs
Stunner! This dress stands out in a crowd!!
Wanted for formal Chrismas party. It seems most go for LBDs for formal affairs. This is a standout in a sea of black. I ordered a size or so bigger than normal. Glad I did. It fit well...but, confortable. I was concerned it may make me look bulky with so much dress. But, I think it was perfect!
Size Worn: 4R
Usual Size: 0
Jennifer rogersTop Contributor
Size 0
5' 4"
108 lbs
Petite
34C
31 yrs
Absolutely loved the dress.
Very elegant.
Size Worn: 4R
Usual Size: 4
Guerin Top Contributor
Size 4
5' 10"
125 lbs
Athletic
36 yrs
Loved it!
I got soooo many compliments!! The fit was a bit loose around my stomach. There is a lot of material so I think if you tend to carry your weight in your tummy you might reconsider this dress, I just sucked it in all night!
Size Worn: 4R
Usual Size: 4
RTR MemberTop Contributor
Size 4
5' 7"
135 lbs
Full Bust
34D
Dress makes you look & feel like an Oscar statue!!
It runs true to size. I'm 5'3" and 125 pounds, I had 5 in heels on, and the regular still brushed the floor. I had to steam the dress because the bottom hem was wrinkled, so you may need to do that before wearing. Looks so much better than just out of the box! Once on, it was a stunning dress! Received compliments all night!!
Size Worn: 4R
Usual Size: 2
LizTop Contributor
Size 2
5' 3"
125 lbs
Hourglass
34B
45 yrs
It was the perfect dress for the Great Gatsby party we attended.
The overall fit was great, except it ran smaller than what I typically wear. It was a little tight around the hip area, but it was flattering for my hourglass shape. It fit well on the shoulder and was the perfect length with a 3"heel.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 12R
Usual Size: 10
RachelTop Contributor
Size 10
5' 8"
165 lbs
Hourglass
32F
34 yrs
Dress makes you feel like a goddess!
I ordered a back-up dress, different designer, also size 6. That fit like a glove and was amazing and I'm glad I did so. If this dress had fit, it would have been a tough decision on what to wear because this gown is amazing. The material, the flow.... having said that - the 6 was HUGE!
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 6
RTR MemberTop Contributor
Size 6
5' 8"
127 lbs
Athletic
36B
53 yrs
The perfect gown for my gala!!
I was one of four event chairs for a charity gala which required me to get on stage and speak in front of 600 people, so I needed something glamorous. This dress did not disappoint! I received so many compliments and loved how it looked on me. The color is a gorgeous champagne color and the fit was amazing and hugged all the right curves. I'm definitely sad to have to send it back!
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 6
BrittneyTop Contributor
Size 6
5' 3"
130 lbs
Petite
34B
28 yrs
Felt like I could be at the Oscars
Absolutely gorgeous dress, wore it to a gala. A 2L was very true to size. At 5'8" the dress was a little long in heels but better than too short!
Size Worn: 2L
Usual Size: 4
ChelseaTop Contributor
Size 4
5' 8"
125 lbs
Pear
32C
26 yrs
Stunning
I was a bridesmaid for a wedding where the bride asked us to wear silver. This dress was a hit! It was elegant and I received compliments the entire day!
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 10
RTR MemberTop Contributor
Size 10
5' 5"
Hourglass
46 yrs
Stand-out dress
A little snug below the waist, but I have extremely wide hips! Length was perfect and overall the dress fit very well. Lots of compliments!
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 8R
Usual Size: 6
RTR MemberTop Contributor
Size 6
5' 4"
145 lbs
Pear
36B
28 yrs
RTR Team Review
This Carmen Marc Valvo gown sets off such a “goddess-y” feel and is perfect for any formal affair. Running true to size, we recommend sizing up for backup. With no stretch in the fabric and a tighter fit in the bust, this piece is better for smaller cup sizes. If you’re curvier, especially in the hips, you may want to consider sizing up for your primary size. Something I love about this gown is the accentuated mermaid style with rouching detail throughout the body. Pair with sleek jewelry and silver heels and all eyes will be on you!
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 4R
Usual Size: 8
KaylaTop Contributor
Size 8
5' 5"
140 lbs
Straight & narrow
34DD
21 yrs
Goddess
Overall, I loved this dress! A stranger told me I looked like a Greek goddess. It's tighter in the thighs than in the bust. So I was slightly squeezed at the bottom and loose on top. Only slightly. But my second size was too big all around. The reason for not giving it the full amount of stars is because my particular dress was showing visible signs of wear. Lots of threads sticking out. Some I ignored, some I had to cut off. It also smelled a bit musty and I had to let it air out for a day. But for the most part, I enjoyed my time with the dress.
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 6
KellyTop Contributor
Size 6
5' 6"
Hourglass
30 yrs
Glittery glam
This dress definitely has wow factor. Lots of compliments thrown my way. The dress was comfortable and surprisingly easy to move around in. The only issue I had was that the inner lining was a little torn at the bottom, and at one point my heel got stuck in a rip and almost tripped me. Fit was pretty good, but all of the detailing can make you look a little paunchy around the middle. If you don't mind that, I say it's a solid yes.
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 6
AureaTop Contributor
Size 6
5' 6"
130 lbs
Athletic
32B
38 yrs
Short!
This was a great dress, but it ran really short. I'm 5'5" and the hem was not touching the floor even in flats. Order the Long size if you are my height or taller!
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 10
BrynnenTop Contributor
Size 10
5' 5"
160 lbs
Hourglass
34C
36 yrs
Forgiving cut
I liked this dress-- it worked perfectly for the event I attended. The cut is forgiving, so I was not concerned about needing shapewear. I did find that it ran a little small, as I sized up and the fit was still snug. The length was a tad short in the front, but not enough to be a big deal.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 8
MeaganTop Contributor
Size 8
5' 2"
165 lbs
Athletic
36B
33 yrs
Felt Like the Oscars!
Wore this to hubby's promotion gala at the Met. Everyone loved it, and I looked and felt like a million bucks. The hem was ripped though! Nearly perfect dress.
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 6
AntoniaTop Contributor
Size 6
5' 7"
145 lbs
Pear
34B
36 yrs
Beautiful metallic dress
Overall this was a beautiful dress. The picture with the model makes the dress appear silver but in real life it leans towards a metallic bronze/silver which turned out to be hard to match to my husband’s bow tie! I wore the 2P which was true to size to slightly larger. I was wearing 3.5in heels and the end of the dress still brushed the ground to the point where people were stepping on the dress throughout the night! The shape and one shoulder were super flattering except for the flap of fabric right over my stomach. In general the dress was super comfortable, perfect for the navy ball, and received lots of compliments!
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 2P
Usual Size: 2
AndreaTop Contributor
Size 2
5' 2"
120 lbs
Petite
32B
27 yrs
Didn’t wear this one but fit well & comfortable.
Perfect length for regular sized heels. Stretchy yet comfortable.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 4
MeganTop Contributor
Size 4
5' 6"
Full Bust
36D
37 yrs
Beautiful, "Oscar" style dress!!
I loved this dress and truly felt like a million dollars. The dress was true to size and was comfortable to wear. I received many compliments throughout the night. I had a little extra room in my hips/butt area because my hips are narrow; however, with the details of the dress, it wasn't noticeable. I highly recommend!
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 6
CarolynTop Contributor
Size 6
5' 6"
130 lbs
Athletic
34D
35 yrs
Sparkly and flattering but on the short side.
This gown was comfortable and flattering to a curvy body but even in the 14L, the dress was on the short side. I made it work with flat sandals as this was already a replacement. Compliments all night from strangers and friends alike nonetheless.
Size Worn: 14L
Usual Size: 14
CatelinTop Contributor
Size 14
5' 10"
185 lbs
Hourglass
38D
29 yrs
We attended a ball ....
This was dress was beautiful! Much more sparkly than the picture shows... I normally wear a 10 and the 10L fit great. ( I'm 5'7) the back is a tad longer than the front, which draped beautifully. It was a tad snug under the arms, but not terrible .
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 10L
Usual Size: 10
AmandaTop Contributor
Size 10
5' 7"
36C
42 yrs
Beautiful but too big on me
This is a beautiful dress, but you'd definitely want the right fit. Just enough shine to be stunning without doing full on sequins. It was comfortable trying it on and I loved the tailoring and one strap look. For me, it just wasn't fitted enough, I got the 4,6 and would've needed a 2. I'm typically about a 4. So I thought it ran a little big. Gorgeous dress, I'd rent it again in the right size.
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 4
RTR MemberTop Contributor
Size 4
5' 8"
125 lbs
Straight & narrow
34B
36 yrs
Great for Curves!!!
The color of the dress was a little too metallic for me but the fit made up for it. I have an hourglass figure and it hid all the bad curves while accentuating the good ones ;) Booty looked amazing even without heels. Fits true to size and I did not have to wear a bra. If I were to do it over I would rent the suggested jewelry to go with it because its a little difficult to match. Not my absolute favorite dress I've ever rented from RTR but a good dress all in all.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 10R
RTR MemberTop Contributor
24 yrs
Customer service saved the day
I had originally rented two different dresses for my husband's ball, however both of them had issues and I couldn't wear them. Called customer service and got Colleen who was nothing short of saintly in her patience and understanding and helped me pick out back up dresses which she sent overnight to me. This one was the winner and I'm so glad I got it. Fit like a glove, was very comfortable and surprisingly light. The material looks silver in the picture, but definitely had more of a silver/champagne tone in person. I got a ton of compliments and felt confident. Photographed well too. I was also the only person in this dress and I saw other dresses I was considering on others throughout the night, so I'm really glad I went with this pick. Only 4 stars because the zipper was a MONSTER to zip up. Dress wasn't tight or ill fitting, but that zipper got stuck on every single fold of that material. That is my only complaint though!
Size Worn: 8R
Usual Size: 8
SarahTop Contributor
Size 8
5' 6"
150 lbs
Hourglass
34D
26 yrs
Pretty dress. Comfortable, forgiving in its fit but runs large.
I’m 5’ 6” 137lb wore an 8 but it was baggy. 6 would’ve been perfect.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 8R
Usual Size: 10
StephTop Contributor
Size 10
39 yrs
Underwhelming
This dress was disappointing. I should have ordered a size down. But others had reviewed it as fitting smaller, that was not the case. It did fit shorter than others, but the waist would run true to size. I didn't wear it for my event.
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 10
RTR MemberTop Contributor
Size 10
5' 5"
155 lbs
Hourglass
36C
29 yrs
Beautiful, but would need the long.
I rented this as my backup dress for an NYE gala and it was very beautiful. I'm usually between a 10 and 12 and the 12 fit very nicely. I didn't wear this because I absolutely loved my first choice gown but would definitely consider it again - only making sure they had the Long available. The Regular was too short. I am 5'7' but with very long legs (34" inseam) if that helps anyone. Really nice material and beautiful fit and color. It's a glamorous gown for sure.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 10
AshleyTop Contributor
Size 10
5' 8"
170 lbs
36C
34 yrs
Great dress. Looks great on. True to size.
This was my first experience with RTR and LOVED IT. Can't wait to use again.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 6
RTR MemberTop Contributor
Size 6
48 yrs
