Exactly what I wanted for cold New England weather

It’s hard to overstate how unflattering this coat is. I’m a size 8 and it made me look like violet beauregarde from Willy Wonka (aka as wide as I am tall) with a humpback. No amount of cinching saves this piece. A spectacularly terrible rental. Returned immediately.

I thought the other reviews were a little dramatic and that this would be oversized in a stylish way but it simply wasn't. It is massive and structured in a way that's actually extremely unflattering.

I live in Colorado and love Renting coats! Sadly I should have paid attention to the other reviews. It is giant. I don't even think sizing down would do the trick as it's just a huge marshmallow and not in a great way! Normally love club Monaco but this was a big miss for me

Most oversized in the wrong way, Ill-fitting coat. Do not rent.

Really big but comfy. With tight pants or tights it's a nice contrast.

I rented this puffer coat for a trip to Yosemite and it was perfect for the snowy weather. Although it is quite puffy, it was really warm and actually ended up being pretty cute!

This jacket will make you look like the marshmallow man, but it is beyond warm. I wore it in 1 degree weather in Montreal. It's better if you unzip it for pictures, but zipped up, you are one big poof.

This is huge. It "fits" but looks MASSIVE on...too much puff.

Was way too puffy. Felt like a marshmallow.

Really warm and pretty I would use a smaller size though

Cute and warm

Cute Basic everyday coat! Super warm! Received tons and tons of compliments. Light weight. I sized down because of the reviews and I am ok with that. However, I like the super puffy look so I may re-rent the medium just to compare! Overall, great rental. I was hesitant because of the few reviews however, I needed a coat in this NY cold and this was perfect

I enjoyed how warm this kept me in below freezing New England temps. Unfortunately my fiancé said I looked like a marshmallow, but I think he was right. I didn't care and rocked it anyways. It was a little too puffy to sit down in the car, but it was extremely warm.

Was enormous

Way too big.

Extremely puffy jacket. I'm really short and it was a lot of fabric.

I love an oversized fit but I was drowning in this jacket. It’s definitely amazing if you’re going somewhere super cold but not great for an everyday jacket

I just think it was way too large and puffy! I looked like a sumo wrestler

It was cumbersome and just too much stuffing for me.

Cute jacket but very puffy - made me look like a marshmallow. Never wore it out

HUGE

It looks huge, I actually look like a herserys kiss in it..

The most ill fitting coat imaginable. Look like the literal Michelin tire man.

I think this coat probably only looks right on very tall, very thin people. I looked so dumpy! I am 5' 2" and a size 0, and this coat looked insane on me. I might have given it another star -- just because it might work on *someone* -- but this coat doesn't even look like the picture.

I should have listened to the reviewers on this platform. Absolutely comical fit, I couldn't wear it! Steer clear, this coat puffs out like a marshmallow or a princess ballgown and is just unwearable.

It is true to size, but it's big, so I would size down just in case.

Love that coat!! Very warm!! Runs a bit large, you should go one size down, M really felt like an L for me, but I loved it.

This jacket is gorgeous - high quality and so cozy. However, it.is.gigantic. Size down unless you are with child, and even then... I'm sending mine back for a smaller size - I might go two down.

This jacket was gigantic. I'm curious to know how a small would look. I usually wear a large and got the medium. It felt like I was wearing a sleeping bag out of the house. Which was actually nice since it was 10 degrees and windy outside. In the words of most moms: "it doesn't matter what it looks like as long as its warm."

Very big

Good quality coat. Seems very warm. But looks way too puffy on me. I wasn't able to pull it off. I am 5"2 and 118lb. Might work better on someone taller

This is oversized in a bad way. You know the giant sideline coats they give football players to cover their pads and bodies? This was a similar look. And I knew it would be large but I thought I would be the exception and it would look great on me. I was wrong.

Order at least 2 sizes down. I took a risk with a Large, however, it was big enough to fit my husband who is 6'4" 250lbs... If you wear M/L, order XS/S.

This coat was missing a drawstring on one side, so it was unwearable I looked to see if it got lost inside, and I could kind of fish it out, but I think it is just gone from the coat completely. Without the drawstrings I sadly couldn't wear it

Warm jacket, but not very flattering!