But I wanted really high pants, enough for a crop top

I'm typically between a size 27 and a 28. I got the 28 in these and they were so tight! Absolutely no stretch to them. When I sat down, the top of the pants dug into my stomach. If I never had to sit down in them, I might have been okay. The two hours I wore them I was miserably uncomfortable. Wish I would have gotten a 29, maybe even a 30.

Loved them so much I bought them somewhere else! These are so flattering and unique. Tons of compliments and perfect for spring. I am a true zero with VERY narrow hips - if you are between sizes definitely go with the bigger one. It is a true thick denim with little stretch. These would be so cute with a white tank and light denim jacket too!

I absolutely adore these - and may keep them! Very slimming.

These jeans were really high waisted and fit me perfectly. They hit my ankle exactly where they should and hit just above my belly button. I paired them with a top from rent the runway as well. I got so many compliments on my outfit. I am sad to return these jeans, but eager to rent them again! Absolutely loved!!!

I LOVED these jeans! I'm short-waisted AND high-waisted, so these came up to my actual waist and for once, I didn't have "bucket butt!" The fabric is a really nice, sturdy denim, but not too heavy. Though it says 100% cotton and other reviewers felt it had no stretch, it does have a bit of "give," just enough to be comfortable while still doing what "old school" jeans used to: it holds your stomach flatter and lifts you in the back. I have a 31"inseam, and I never expect the length to be like the model's, but these came down to my ankles like regular skinny jeans. I just rolled them for a cropped look. They ARE very bubblegum pink, but pastels and colors like this are on-trend. I just had to be careful to pair them with neutrals, otherwise I might've looked like "The Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt!" I wore them 2 or 3 times though, and if they'd been a color that wasn't so "oh there are those pink jeans again," I might've bought them, but again, the fit was so flattering compared to most skinny jeans on my somewhat problematic legs that I'll definitely rent any pair from Current/Elliot and probably start buy this brand.

Cute denim. I should have sized down, but they were fine. Enjoyed the pop of color for sure!

I preface my saying these run large by saying I wear this size, 28, in JCrew and Levis, but many other brands are way too small for me in 28 because of my large calves and butt. This fit the butt and calves with no waist gap. There is almost no stretch to the fabric, so I was pleased with the fit and comfort. Most of my pants just feel like leggings with pockets. I had a hard time getting them off because of my calves. I ended up buying these.

These jeans are adorable. Wore them for Valentine's Day. I'm postpartum so they felt a bit tight on me (still adjusting to my different size). Just note they have no stretch so if in doubt on your size, definitely size up.

Material is like a rough canvas and fit doesn't work for me. Color is fun and length is perfect for 5'3"

Cute pants, but super thick with 0 stretch. A little impractical for Texas summer! They weren't as high waisted as i hoped.

The color is gorgeous but the material was too heavy for me in the NC heat and humidity. Would be great for fall or spring when it's cooler

These jeans have no stretch or give so 100% size up! The 27 fit perfectly. I read similar reviews about sizing and everyone was right. I don't mind jeans with no stretch if the sizing works out, so I think this item deserves a higher rating. The color is so playful and memorable. Perfect for renting with a cozy cropped sweater from John + Jenn. I thought they were high waisted enough despite reading other reviews. Very flattering and got so many compliments at work.

I kept getting happy every time I saw my legs, so these will definitely be a repeat item. Wore it with a loose black sweater to tone it down, which was perfect. It was not the comfiest pair of jeans ever, though. I'm usually a 30 and the 31 fit with noooo room to spare in the waist.

Rent the Runway recommended I order a 24. I should have known to order 25. If these were a little stretchy like most of my jeans these days it would have worked but these were old school denim stiff. I stuffed myself in them anyway for the night -- was even able to sit down and eat dinner. Looked great but not comfortable.

Runs super small - I normally wear a 27. Cute, but stiff material and I was glad to take them off. Did get compliments though!

I'm a 25 and the 26 was tight at the waist and fit just okay everywhere else Bubble gum pink No stretch High waisted Wish I could have worn these sizing off

Size up

I ordered these jeans for a concert, and they honestly would have been perfect if they weren't so small. I'm normally either a 6 or 8, so I ordered the 8 after seeing reviews saying they are a bit snug. They were so small, I could barely get them on and certainly couldn't button them (not even close). I guess I should have gone with another size up, but I honestly suspect that I might need 2 or more sizes up before they would fit me. Very disappointed because they were cute.

I should've believed the reviews; there is NO stretch to these. I couldn't get them on.

Went with the size RTR recommended and it's so small I can't wear it. So annoyed since without unlimited I lost a spot. I wish they would get sizing correct on here!

Very sturdy, high quality denim. I loved the high waisted look, finally got to wear crop tops to work

If you don't enjoy wearing bright BRIGHT clothes, this is not for you. My director commented on how I stood out on the other side of a football field-sized conference room and said he needed to wear shades when I got in close proximity; lol. It's a fun wear; perfect to welcome in Spring, especially after dreary gray-rainy days.

Nice fit

Loved these jeans...wore casually with a cute white top and slides. Perfect fit and length for me 5' 5" Also loved the higher rise. I will definitely rent again!

Not stretchy jeans, so be prepared for that. I usually wear denim with a little stretch, but this is old-school, thick denim that does not stretch. So, sizing is really important.

I went up 2 sizes and they stretched out way too big. Go with your regular size. Struggle to button and they probably will be perfect. If you r really thick n middle this is probably not a good idea

perfect fit, appreciated the high waist to hide my stomach

Great pop of color that goes nicely with a white top.

I have muscular legs and these were too tight for me, so if you have an athletic or curvy build, I recommend sizing up.

Cute color & cut, but no stretch.

These don't stretch at all. Also this brand tends to conch at the waist which I don't understand it causes a muffin top. The color is awesome and I think illl try the next size up

I loved the material and color but they were a little to snug around my waist to wear out. Im usually a size 2 but i dont go in much at the waist. Fit everywhere else was great.

Runs small, I would size up. Jeans do stretch out so I wouldn't size up more than once. The color is super cute and the high waist fit is awesome.

Too tight because of the high waist.

No surprises here, just pink jeans. These have no stretch at all and are very thick. I rented these during the summer so will send back and re-rent during the cooler months.

Pros: Cute color, pretty comfortable fabric. I also received a new with tags pair, so that was a nice bonus. Cons: Fit was slightly too tight on my thighs, but looser in waist. Made them almost like a dropped crotch style because I couldn't pull the inseam all the way, even though the waist area was loose. ALSO: These are pretty long, they are not cropped length like the photo suggests, I had to roll them up/cuff them at the ankle.

Super fun color and flattering. Waist is small and they are not forgiving.

The color is awesome bubblegum pink, but I think these won't fit me in any size. I have larger calves and so they barely made it on my legs and were too loose on the hips and waist. If you are curvier, they are cut too straight to fit well I think.