A very dense top (not too structured but heavy fabric) with a glamorous look! Perfect for cold weather. I wore a Large (nursing Mama who's in between sizes - 6/8 normally and 36D+) but definitely could have worn a Medium as it does have some give in the fabric. Color is beautiful.

Really high quality top, lot of cute detail, but made me look about 15 lbs heavier!

This shirt was cozy. I have an 8 piece membership and got this for something different. It was oversized and not particularly flattering, but I was going for cozy and comfy! It was great as a work from home piece. The material is very thick, which is great for fall/winter and I loved the color.

The material is comfortable but it is much heavier than it appears to be in the photos. It is definitely a winter weight. It fit well but the sleeves were very long. I was able to tuck them underneath so it wasn't a problem. It is a beautiful fall color and definitely an expensive feeling and looking material.

Fits like a lampshade but I liked it! Fabric is thick and nice feeling

It's a nice thick material, but not the easiest to pull the turtle neck over your head if you have your hair done. But, I loved the color. It was cozy to wear all day.

Couldn't get a good angle in the picture but this is a lovely sweater. Loved it with high waisted jeans as the peplum part of the top has a bit of space there (wore Levi's black skinnies from RTR in this pic). Definitely renting again!

Really excited to have loved this so much. I wear your standard tight black turtleneck almost everyday, so the color and shape of this one is so fun. I paired it over the Alexis Leopard Lydia dress and a moto jacket- super cute and fashion forward, warm too! The material is similar to a knitted scuba.

Pretty sure I'll end up buying it by the end of the day. Love it.

This sweater is a nice deep orange/red color. The S fit me perfectly and as others have said, the sleeves are long. This didn't bother me and the sleeves looked fine folded up. The high quality of the sweater is definitely noticeable in the thickness of material; this being said, I wasnt too hot in it. It is a stretchy material. Love the flare, was able to wear to work.

I loved this top for work or everyday. It is extremely thick and sturdy, but very comfortable with a good amount of stretch. It is wide but still flattering. Great fall color!

This sweater is fabulous, especially with some high waisted jeans! Such great heavy fabric and beautiful detail. I received so manh compliments on it, I want to keep it so badly :)

Rented for Thanksgiving! Got many compliments from family and friends! Loved the color and cut! The sleeves were very long, but I liked them rolled up. Comfy and stylish, really enjoyed this rental! I wore my usual size M.

Love this shirt! It's a perfect color and material for fall or winter. I wore it out to dinner and it looked great with black jeans and tall boots or booties. It can easily be dressed up or down. The structured pleats are flattering and unique and it runs true to size. The only downside was that the material was thicker than I expected--I was a little hot at dinner. Besides that, I would definitely rent this again and highly recommend it!

Thick, fitted, delicious material. Perfect for winter. I will purxhase as soon as it foes on sale! Definitely a gorgeous piece. Wore it with dark denim and thigh high suede black boots to a party.

This fit great. Love the color. Wore it for dinner with friends.

The fabric was thick, making this sweater quite warm. The flounces at the bottom are well constructed. A really unique, interesting piece. I wish I could keep it.

Structured high-quality perfection. This top is beautiful and eye-catching. I want to purchase it very badly.

Worn for my annual friendsgiving party. Many many compliments and great for eating everything and worrying about nothing!

Loved this turtleneck! I got a size medium and was very happy with my decision. I will say that the neck was tighter than I expected because the material was not an every day knit but more of a heavy needle knit. I would recommend sizing up if you're unsure! The color was also really strong, especially for Fall. LOVE

The burnt orange color is perfect for fall! The material is very nice and its loose fitting and flattering for any body type. Thought it would look too oversized and maternity like but not the case! Loved it! So many compliments. Wore it to work and for brunch

This shirt was super comfortable and kept me warm during these breezy beginning fall days. I wore it with a pair of dark blue jeans and heel booties. I loved the color, and the style! You can dress it up or dress it down. I highly recommend renting this shirt, it's probably one of my favorite selections I've made on RTR so far!

This really isnt my color. Well made and interesting, but would not rent again.

Comfortable sweater, snug in shoulders but fabric is forgiving. The sleeves are SUPER long. I folded them up and it worked. Great fall color. I wore this to work and then out to dinner with friends.

Got a ton of compliments on this one. The color is so great, especially if you are like me and wear black a lot. Can dress it up or down. I did rent the small though and I normally would wear a medium so size down on this one.

I rented this shirt for normal day-to-day wear and wore it to work with black jeans. Overall I liked it and received several compliments. Pros: trendy without trying too hard; substantial material; overall pretty comfortable; hung well on my body. Cons: didn't quite fit right in the shoulders; color didn't really suit me. But the biggest con for me was the way the fabric hit my chin / neck. I liked the material everywhere else, but by the end of the day by chin / neck were starting to hurt a bit from the way the rougher material was rubbing against them. Overall, this was a good rental as part of my Unlimited plan, but I shipped it back the morning after I wore it. With items I love, I usually keep them for a few more days to try and find other opportunities to wear them. This was good for a one time rental, but compared to other items I've rented and loved, I'm not sure I'll rent it again.

Hangs nicely, but is a very full flowy top. Not fitted at all. Great for a fun day shopping in the elements!

Cute top. I'm a size 6-8 and felt I should have ordered a small instead of medium. Quality was phenomenal!

Needed a turtleneck for a cold vacation but don't expect much more than that. Color is a little too rusty for my taste.

It was not my favorite, but still wore it 3 times! Very nice, heavy material. Just an odd lenth and flare. Took a close up so you can see the material

Didnt really like anything about this shirt. It felt frumpy, the arms were incredibly long and not fitted, the material was very stiff, heavy and uncomfortable. From the side I looked like I was wearing a lamp shade. Not flattering at all.

The sleeves are long, but I cuffed them and it was fine. Loved this top and wore it multiple times!

Loved this shirt for a comfortable, but stylish work option. Runs large, I could have sized down. Also, sleeves are super long so I had to fold them up quite a bit.

Color is stunning ochre. Fit is trapeze but structured on top and through arms. The craftsmanship is really good. Very expensive looking.

Color was fun, very cute shape, but did not wear because it was too wide in the shoulders. I typically wear an 8/10 or medium, and I should have rented the small

Flattering fit. Nice thick fabric. Sleeves are very long, but was able to role them up.

This is a beautiful top, the material is heavy and will keep you warm in mild weather. This is a regular top but it loose and swingy enough that I was able to wear it in my 4th month of pregnancy and I didn't look pregnant

So into the rust color for the fall. Very warm and comfy but sleeves definitely long as per other reviews but folding along cuff was fine and looked like it came like that. Will def rent again

Loved everything about this sweater. Great, rich-feeling fabric. Beautiful color. Typical turtleneck with a twist.