It was the perfect top for the occasion

I wore this sweater more times than any other RTR rental ever. It is really soft and I just LOVED the extra-long sleeve styling. I love where it hits at the waist.

I like the asymmetrical hemline on this sweater. The sleeves are very long, even past the point of fashionable I think. How am I supposed to hold a drink? I love the rich, red color. The shoulders have significant hanger bumps from being on the hanger. This illusion ads to the someone unfavorable fit. But I'm going to wear it anyway.

The sweater is very soft and warm. I felt like it was true to size. The sleeves were extremely long. I have them rolled up a third time.

Love this sweater, but the arms had grown from hanging. I have double rolled them to compensate. May need to order 1 size smaller for all sweaters going forward. Would love it there was a way to fold sweaters into a pocket bag to hang, but not change the shape of the garment.

Crazy long sleeves. Hung down beyond my hands even when folded In the way intended. Would have had to triple fold to be the right length.

Wore multiple times, very flattering.

I actually loved this sweater! I was super skeptical based on the other reviews, but it was cute, casual, and a little different (in a good way :) ). I ended up rolling the sleeves one more time than it originally came and it looked super cute.

awesome fit

sporty and chic

Fun, casual piece that's warm and easy to pair with a spectrum of coordinates.

Sleeves are long, but that shows in the picture. Its really comfortable and warm so great to where whenever!

great fit

Glamorous

Obsessed with this sweater and I haven't even worn it yet-- fresh out of the bag and I'm in love! might just have to buy it

on my long-ish torso, the sweater itself was almost too short. Still, super cute, fun for brunch or casual date

Runs large, sleeves are super long but the sweater itself is so pretty and great material

I had read the previous reviews on this sweater and found them to be correct. The sleeves are VERY long! I have average measurements with broad shoulders, so I felt it would probably fit fine, but I was wrong. The sleeves were so long that I found it uncomfortable. It kept me warm and the material was found to be very comfortable, but I most likely will not rent this again.

The color, cut, and style of the sweater is great! The sleeves are just extremely long (I'm 5'7" and they reached my knees), so be prepared to roll them up to your elbows. It doesn't look bad, just have to roll throughout the day.

The arms were incredibly long, I had to fold them twice which made it bulky and uncomfortable with my jacket. The quality and color was nice. It was a little shorter than I would like.

Long sleeves

comfy, looked great

the sleeves are super super long!

Sleeves too long even if rolled up twice. Also did not fit in shoulders

The other reviewers were right - the sleeves were so long - like nearly a foot too long - that this sweater wasn't wearable. Bummer, because the color was nice.

When my daughter saw me pull this out of the bag she could not stop laughing. "The sleeves!!!!!" she kept saying then collapsing in giggles. They are SO long. I get that they are supposed to fold over in long cuffs but all the way up to the elbow? And I have pretty long arms. And the rest of the sweater was nothing special. A little boxy, not a lot of detail. An immediate return for me.

It's obvious by the picture that the sleeves are meant to be a little long, however, the material is too heavy to keep the sleeves rolled up.

I usually wear a small, but I got this top in an extra small and the shoulders were much too wide and the sleeves were very long so I couldn't wear it. Disappointed, because it was so cute otherwise!

Sleeves are crazy long on this and even folded up would come to my elbows. I felt I was swimming in it.

I know the idea was for the sleeves to be long but they were way too long on me. Didn't even wear it.

The sleeves are super long but the shoulders were super awkward on my body. I'm sure this would be cute on someone with more narrow shoulders.

Sleeves is too long. Unwearable

Sleeves were so ridiculously long it it was unwearable. Plus shoulders were way too wide.

The sweater sleeves were way too long, I did not wear the sweater.

The sleeves are ridiculously long - you can't role roll them up or scrunch them. The sleeves literally go to your knees

Arms so long its ridiculous

Sleeves too long and the torso too short

OMG who designed this sweater?? I read the reviews and thought surely the reviewers were being dramatic about the long sleeves. I rented the XS and am about 5' 4". From shoulder to wrist my arm is 21 inches long. Guess how long the sweaters arms are - 33 INCHES!!! So unless you are 7 feet tall and have long arms to match, this will NOT work for you. Also there is so much fabric that you can't just cuff/ roll up the sleeves without it looking like you are wearing wrist weights underneath. Save yourself the trouble and pass on this one.