The sleeves were a little bit itchy (my skin is admittedly sensitive) so I wouldn't wear it without long sleeves. However, because of the heft of the material it's actually quite warm and so I'd recommend it for cold spring/cold autumn days!

This is a nice weighty cardigan that can be worn in black or navy. It holds its shape so well that it can be swapped for a blazer with most outfits. Really an exceptional piece.

This was my go-to Florida winter "coat." Warm enough for a 40 degree short walk. No button in the front, so it wouldn't be warm for long. It is reversible, between black and blue, which was great between black slacks or blue jeans.

Rented for work and life while 7.5 months pregnant. Such a lovely cut and fabric. Easily the best quality piece I've rented in a while. Was so nice to wear a duster with some shape for once, as opposed to a dumpy maternity cardigan. You definitely don't need to be pregnant to rent this, but wow what a nice change of pace for those who are.

Breathable. Cozy. Ideal length. If a ti e and a sweater had a baby, it would be this sweater.

Great quality, nice material, but it flares out strangely at the bottom which I didn't find flattering

A nice 100% wool piece. Nothing special. Very heavy and kind of "blocked." No movement.

Also kind of itchy. Wouldn't recommend.

Wish I could buy this as I'd wear it every day!

Turns inside out for navy or black. Perfect warm wool transitional overcoat

Very comfortable

Larger fit, but beautiful draping and construction. Reversible Navy/ black

I get lots of compliments on this. I am keeping it for another month.

Great quality and cut. Approximately oversized for the style. Contrasting liner is a nice touch.

Love it!

This sweater is super warm and comfortable, perfect for everyday weekend wear. The only thing is it was pretty big - I recommend sizing down, although the size didn't bother me much!

This has been one of my favorite items from RTR- It's warm, comfy, and looks classy

Very high quality

Love the fit and look of this heavy sweater/coat. Didn't realize it was reversible until after wearing it once. Draped really nicely and was warm enough to wear as a jacket.

It's so heavy weight, perfect as a light coat alternative. It's definitely not cardigan like material as is thick wool. I am a size 6 and got a medium, which is huge.

Warm!!

Very boxy, but super warm, ended up wearing around the house to keep warm. Didn't end up wearing it out. Attracts a ton of lint and dog hair too. But super warm!

Only hard part was deciding how to wear it, because it could go with tons of outfits. Very thick and good quality, it didn't feel like the sleeves were stretching as the day went on. It is very long though.

Just FYI, the lining is navy blue. I ended up wearing it only once as a result, since I generally wear all-black outfits.

Very long and heavy, but good quality. Would be nice in the winter.

More like a coat than a sweater. Reverses from black to navy. Nice but not WOW.

Thick, warm, soft and super comfy. Perfect for lounging around the house. A little casual for work, quite honestly - definitely has bathrobe vibes. Goes to just below the knee. The way the sweater is cut makes it hang oddly - there is a slit up the sides to about upper knee/mid-thigh area, which makes for separate back, left, and right panels - and with the material the way it is (almost a felted, substantial knit), the panels stuck out instead of draping smoothly and it looked frankly a little ridiculous. That being said, I still wore it every day for a week!

Too big in shoulders

I love this duster but it's very thick and warm for running errands when it's rainy and 50 degrees. I'll consider it again for the dead of winter

If you are short this does not go to mid thigh, more like mid shin.