Fits oversized which is what I prefer. If you don’t like an oversized fit, size down.

So chic! Love the dark green color. I wore with leggings and a fitted shirt for my bougie soccer mom lewk 😂

I loved this vest! The material is great. I would say it’s slightly big, just a little long if I’m being picky but overall fit really well! Like other reviews said, the color is a dark green not black but I didn’t mind the color!

Loved this. I popped it on for everything — work, groceries, brewery, dog walks, etc. Very dark green that it almost looks black. Oversized, but just looks cool. If I rent again I might size down, but the extra oversized-ness didn’t bother me.

Runs large but that's the point! RTR site does make the vest appear black but I didn't mind the dark green. Literally wore this dozens of times and still want to purchase! Great layered over almost anything but my go to was a hoodie. Also very warm for Chicago winters!

Received tons of compliments with this one. Appears black in almost all pics but is dark green

First of all - so on trend right now! Second - keeps you so warm without having to wear a big coat! I want this as a staple in my closet and I got SO MANY compliments on this!

Could have sized down to a xs but I wanted a more oversized fit. I definitely thought it was black when I rented it but I guess I didn't read the description closely because it's a dark green. Still super cute! Was pretty warm too

Overall I loved this vest it’s just not black and more like dark green and it’s also very big despite getting a small and especially for someone who is short it’s not as flattering as I would like but it’s a great quality vest. I would size down!

The shoulders on this are so wide and the entire thing is so large I would recommend sizing down at least one size, but still not sure that would do it

Bummer but I ordered a medium based on recommended sizing and felt like a football player. The vest is huge and I think it’s supposed to be that way-but not my style at all. Was looking more for a vest that fit better like my North Face puffer I’ve had for years!

Would recommend for fall instead of winter because it doesn't layer well with thicker jackets but otherwise is a chic and comfortable vest option!

I wore this almost every day on a trip to Ireland in September. It's just warm enough and great for layering. As others have said it's a dark green but beautiful nonetheless

I do, apparently. Perfect over everything. Wrong in all of the right ways.

Wore a ton, loved it

I absolutely loved this vest. I could throw it over any outfit, and feel effortlessly pulled together. Great for cool but not freezing weather, where wearing a a coat over your sweater or hoodie would be too warm.

I hesitate to rent fake leather as it's often noisy and very very hot. This had a silky lining, nice outer material, and didn't feel like a sauna. Also, it's green, not black.

This is SUCH a cute piece. I've worn it over a sweatshirt with leggings and it really elevates the casual outfit and is soooo snuggly and warm. Also work over a black bodysuit with jeans. Easy to throw on, truly so warm and cozy.

This was a super cute versatile piece. Super warm and always got compliments. Still contemplating whether to pull the trigger and buy it.

I wore this almost every day i had it. Great for transitioning weather and if you wear something thick enough underneath you can wear this in cooler areas. Super chic and comfy.

Got an XS bc it was available and it fit well!! I am usually a S in tops but this is super roomy. And warm. Great rental!

Literally the perfect street syle piece!

I loved this vest, I wore it all the time while I had it and will definitely be renting again! I wore with jeans and a tight long sleeve turtleneck underneath and it really elevated the look!

I had been eyeing this vest to buy and when I saw it on RTR I was so excited to rent -- I wore it so, so often and it got tons of compliments. It is oversized for sure and has slight shoulder pad look, but that made it fun and easy to dress up and down. Perfect for NYC!

Perfect vest! Shoulders extend a little more than normal but I liked the cut a lot! Deep comfy pockets. Kept me warm and I looked stylish!

Didn’t like the shoulders

This is a staple. I should buy it.

Love the faux leather version of a trendy puffer vest!

Wore an XS and it was still pretty large / bulky. But super warm also!

This is very cute! It's sooo soft, very puffy, and very boxy. The color is a lovely green and not black. I took off one star because I felt it wasn't super flattering, but it was definitely fun and warm.

Fit was big

I read reviews saying it ran large. the xs was taken so i thought i’d give the small a try— this is my usual size. It swallowed me. didn’t end up wearing this one it was just too big.

The style is very boxy but material and overall quality were great. It wasn’t the right look for me.

The shoulders on this vest are really oversized so, for me, it was very unflattering. on the hanger it looked great but didn't work for me.

This is my second time trying this vest. I keep sizing down, and it is still HUGE. Most of the fluff inside was squished to the front, so parts of the vest were just fabric and no "puff". It's also almost green, rather than black.

Green not black

I thought this would be more of a crop vest but it was HUGE! I legit looked like the leather michelin man

I didn’t wear it. It is hugeeeee