I rented the small and medium sizes. I tried on both and the small was perfect. Depending on what brand I am wearing determines which size I am. I am tall, and slender. So with being slender, the small fits body wise. But with being tall, the medium helps with length in torso material and sleeves. But Bailey 44 made these sweaters just right for me. The small size fit me perfect. Wasn't too short or too tight. Fit me so well and was so soft. A very comfortable sweater. We went to a pumpkin patch and corn maze. It was just the right look with the splash of orange. I loved wearing this sweater and made note that I need it in my wardrobe. I have been searching everywhere for it, trying to purchase it for myself!

Comfy and unique ... great color. A great rental. Want to buy!!

I'm so upset that this is literally the only photo I have in this sweater! This sweater is comfortable and so unique I really loved it. Would love to have kept it forever! Highly recommend!

I freaking love this sweater. Great colors, super comfy, easy to dress up or down. I might buy this as a birthday present to myself

Fits true to size, cute zipper detail, interesting color combo but was a little worn. Wore at work and out with family and received lots of compliments.

I liked the dark navy blue color and the asymmetrical zipper. The fit was good, not too tight, not to baggy.

This is a wonderful sweater. Loved wearing it. Wore it super bowl Sunday to represent the super bowl 50 camps the Denver Broncos !! Lucky sweater?! It was well made - tons of compliments - warm - comfortable and cozy. Great zipper detail. Wish I could keep it!!

Great casual sweater. Comfortable. Good normal length. Very happy with it.

Fit was great. Zipper could gives you flexibility. Got tons of compliments.

This sweater was very comfortable for a day at work. The fabric wasn't itchy, but not overly soft, either. The colors were more muted than anticipated. There is a zipper along the right side of the sweater that I hadn't noticed and when I say it gave a weird puckering effect that wasn't the most flattering. Overall, it was lovely to wear for a day, but I'm not sure I would rent again.

It fit true to size as most Bailey 44 clothes do. It was cute for dropping the kids off at school and running errands. Not my favorite rental ever but still cute. I liked the pop of orange.

The sweater is lightweight and perfect for fall. The zipper on the side is cute and can be worn opened or closed. I got a medium but could see how someone who would want a looser fit especially with stripes would go up a size than normal. If you're worried about being too tight go up a size.

It's pilling a bit, but it's flattering and fun.

LOVED it, pop of color on the sleeves really uped the look super cute!

I really enjoyed this sweater and received a few compliments. I love the color-blocking and mix of fabrics. It is also a warm sweater with a great zipper detail.

Looks nice on. Comfortable, would rent more items like this

I liked this sweater a lot! It's so modern yet classic. Would have bought if not so worn out. Definitely rent this one, you won't be disappointed!

Fit true to size. Material was light so it's great for fall or spring day. Paired with denim and brown boots. Loved it so much I bought it!

Many complements will rent again

Most of the clothes on RTR are too dressy for my lifestyle, but this sweater was perfect. I have a large bust and often sweaters make me look heavy and frumpy, but cut and material of this one made it fall just right. I love the stripes and the mix of color and pattern. BTW the dark color is navy, not black, as I thought, which made it even cuter than I expected.

I wore a large, flattering fit and very comfortable.

The fit was very relaxed. The sweater is not heavy, so it's comfortable to wear. It definitely amps up any plain outfit. I'm considering adding it to my collection. If you're looking for a heavy super warm sweater, this isn't it. But if you want something to add a little pizzazz to your every day wardrobe, try this on!

This is a great sweater for fall/winter. It is comfortable and perfect for work, errands and the casual dinner. I loved the zipper up front as it added "something" to it. I wore the medium and it was not skin tight, but certainly not looser. I would recommend getting a back up one size up versus down. I would definitely rent again.

Great piece when you want to look stylish without trying too hard. I wore it to work and both my male and female coworkers began dishing out the compliments. My students loved it as well. I am thinking of purchasing this one!

This sweater was very comfortable, but had a nice fit. My boyfriend thought it was very sexy!...Who knew, stripes are sexy! I wish I owned this sweater!!!

This sweater looks amazing on! I loved it. I'm usually a 2/4 and the S fit perfectly. Definitely recommend for an everyday outfit.

Wore it out with my friends in Baltimore. Got a lot of compliments on the bright orange and black combination (go O's!), as well as the zippers. It's fitted but not tight and has a flattering cut that looks good on curves.

I rented this for a trip to Portugal over the holidays and kept it for a few weeks because it looked cute on me. The pops of orange are a nice contrast, and the navy, white and gray coloring make this an easy piece to pair with just about anything. It runs a tiny bit big, but not by much. I'm between a medium and small and went with the medium. It fit but I would probably go with the small next time. Really enjoyed this rental!

Slim fit sweater was perfect for everyday wear. Recommend size up if you have a fuller bust or wide back. Zipepr detail was really cute with flared jeans.

The zipper on it works, so I let it out a few inches to show the detail. It was very comfortable too and fits just as it looks on the model.

The sweater fit was true to size and I wish I didn't have to return it. The zipper detail was a nice addition to the sweater.

Very soft. Got lots of compliments!

I absolutely loved this sweater! The fit was great, and I loved the zipper... which actually unzips! So cozy I would consider buying it!

Was very happy with this soft, fun sweater. I would wear it again.

This sweater is super cute for work. I wanted a looser fit so I sized up (I usually wear a medium), which was perfect because no one wants tight horizontal stripes.

This sweater fit great and was comfortable to wear to work. The one I received looked a bit worn but it still looked great on. The zipper opens up all the way so you can layer a complementary cami underneath

Comfortable and the colorblock + stripes combination is fun. I wore it with jeans.

Unique casual knit perfect for everyday. True to size, I am size 2 and rented M, so it was a bit too big.

I liked the style of this sweater- the stripes and zipper and colors. I'm tall and it was the perfect length. I wore it with white shorts and got compliments on it. The only downside was that it looked like I had owned it for years because it was very worn and there were lots of pilling.

This is a very cute sweater for running around town. I don't think I would order it again because it is pretty "normal." The zipper is cute and the fit is comfortable with plenty of comfort "slouch."