I enjoyed renting this sweater but wouldn't buy it bc it was a tad itchy. If you wear a short sleeved for 3/4 sleeve top underneath you get itchy at Times bc the fabric isn't very soft. The style goes with a lot of different outfits and I got a TON of compliments on it. It feel like it's a statement sweater while still being very neutral. I'm going to look for something similar but in a softer fabric to own! I would rent this again!

I loved how thick and warm it was. The only con was that it was itchy. If you are sensitive to wool, this is not the piece for you. I wore a long sleeve shirt underneath it and that fixed the problem!

The sweater is very thick and warm.

Matches with everything, great fit and comfy.

Super warm and cozy. I wore over a shirt dress but would look adorable with leggings also.

So so warm and cozy, and adorable... though I think that it looks better than it feels on. Would still rent it again!

Great over sized sweater. It was scratchy not not uncomfortable.

It's cozy! Has an under tone of black under the nubs. XS is getting a little of that "loved teddy bear" look from wear I suspect, but it's cozy and warm during this -3 degree week! Casual warm sweater.

This was a cute cardigan sweater and very warm. Well made.

The arms are a tad tight but the sweater is very warm and cozy! Loved this

This sweater is very warm! It is great for running errands when you don't want to wear a bulky coat and is very cute. It was a bit shorter in length than I expected though.

Fit was great and very comfy A little worn - like I owned it; just not that new new look

I thought this made me look a little bulky but my husband and colleagues loved it on me. It was very comfortable and warm.

This sweater is... interesting. It looks like a round rug, and my friends enjoyed making jokes at its expense. I got used to the pattern while wearing it, though, and then it was okay. It's also VERY itchy, so I couldn't wear it with the outfits I chose for it. You definitely need to wear long sleeves under it. The fit was great, a little bulky, but I was going for that, and it did cinch a bit at the waist. I would think a size 6-10 on top could get away with the medium. Any smaller than a 6 should size down. The sleeves were a good length for my long arms. It fits very similar to the model, maybe a little less fluffy.

Fit was right on - nice tailored look and quality quilted material ... just very itchy. Its very warm , but wearing longsleeves under it (to avoid the itching) made me feel like I was roasting !

I planned on wearing this for a weekend at the lake. It seemed cozy for chilly nights... like other reviewers mentioned it was quite itchy. I decided to send it back instead.

The sweater was stiff and not very soft. The sleeves were also awkwardly short for the size.

The sweater is pretty but the fibers are synthetic and do not have a soft feeling. It is a beautiful color and fit, so would recommend if the feel doesn't bother you!

I actually had to check to see if this sweater was actually what I rented when I took it out of the package. It doesn't resemble the picture very well. It was also quite itchy and lacked stretchiness that some sweaters have. Overall I wish I didn't rent it.

Cute, cozy and fun on these cold winter days

If you are looking for a very warm sweater, this is a good choice for you. The material has a lot of texture. For me, it added more bulk than I wanted. It's a nice layering piece, cute with a turtleneck and jeans as shown in the model photo.

I rented for casual wear but it runs small and was too bulky looking on me. Its very nice quality but didn't suit me, I never wore it.

I got this sweater and returned it the next day. It was pilled up and looked old and worn. Bummer because it looked cute online when it was new