The fur collar had an interesting smell, which my husband said smelled like mothballs, but it didn't bother me. Also, the closure snaps didn't stay closed very well so it would bust open pretty easily. But other than those things, I loved it!!

This jacket was so great, I highly recommend. I was really surprised by how much I loved this style. It had a great oversized, boyfriend fit so I definitely recommend sizing down. The fur color is removable but I wore it attached because it made it that more special. I wore this in NYC winter so it will keep you warm on the chillier days but is great over a top on the warmer winter afternoons.

I sized down one but didn't need to with my height 5ft 7. True to size. The smaller size still fit but lost some of the oversized look. Note this coat is short at the back, just covered my butt. Very warm. Collar makes this coat. Nice big pockets. Has bat sleeves.

Definitely one of my favorite outerwear rentals! Loved the look & weight of this jacket. It kept me warm, especially with the added fuzz. ;) You can remove it but I thought it looked better with it on. My one complaint is that the buttons tend to not stay shut (and although I'm pregnant, there was plenty of room in there so it wasn't the bump that kept opening the jacket).

It's HUMUNGOUS. I honestly had reservations about wearing it when I first got it because it was SO large. I usually wear a 10 but I sized up for layers in a long NYC weekend. But it's such a baller coat I didn't care about the oversize.

I had a work event in late November that required standing outside, meeting people, networking, and handing out fliers. I needed to stay warm and look professional. I got so many compliments on the coat- it did a lot of the "socializing" work for me :) it was a conversation starter. I really want to buy it. Highly recommend! Oh also, I love that the drape of the collar and the sleeves are roomier, so you can actually fit it over a heavier sweater.

I wore this coat a million times and almost kept it! It reminds me of old Hollywood! Its not going to make you look thin, but the stunning collar is so worth it.

Loved the oversize style - its a cocoon coat so its MEANT to be big. The sleeves have sort of a dolman sleeve cut to them, which actually makes this the perfect coat for winter layers with comfort. It's so warm with the collar. It's a head-turner, for sure. Be bold and wear it big. Just gotta own it.

This jacket kept me warm all winter long thanks to unlimited. The cocoon shape and understated grey color are flattering and modern. I received so many compliments, particularly from a stylist friend who recognized it as a riff off of a runway jacket (can't remember the designer). I wore it with the fur collar off with a blanket scarf. Super adorable!

This coat is well made, totally fabulous and important, very warm. I went 2 sizes down and found the oversize of that fit to be perfect and super on trend. I wore it on very cold New York City nights and it was perfect. Very tempted to buy!

Ran a little big, but I loved the oversize fit. Kept me warm on a 20 degree NYC night.

I sized up for a bigger fit! There was easily plenty of room for under layers and I probably could have worn a 10. The fur collar is detachable but stays securely on. Snap buttons. The coat was warm especially with the collar on. I didn't want to send it back!!

This coat was absolutely beautiful. I loved the fur collar; however, it did take me a few tries to button it on properly. I attached it incorrectly the first day and just couldn't figure out what I was doing wrong. Great fit once the collar is on! This coat is for cold weather, so be sure the season is right.

Very warm coat. Absolutely loved the fur collar.....actually returning so I can get a smaller size as the coat was extremely too big in a Size 6.

I wanted this coat to work but it was just wayyy too big. It looked silly it was so big. I did end up wearing the fur as a separate but did not wear the coat since it was too large. I've been a fan of this coat for a long time but was reluctant to rent because of reviews of it being so large. I finally decided to go for it but it didn't necessarily work out unfortunately. It's a beautiful coat but if you have similar measurements, I recommend renting another coat - you would be swimming in this. While sometimes oversized clothing looks stylish and chic, this coat was so big it looked ridiculous. Love RTR but this one wasn't for me. If you order go 2 (maybe 2 or more) sizes down.

Went with my backup jacket as this was too large. I was swimming in it!

Had to return for smaller size. Got the 4 but need a 0. Coat runs very large but nice quality and love the fur collar

This is a beautiful coat with a cool vibe but it runs large and that combined with boxy style just didn't work for me. I sent it back without wearing because I was drowning in it.

I wanted to love this. It is big and bulky so not really flattering, but I knew that going in. The big deal breaker was the fur. I spent so much time attaching it, but couldn't figure out which buttons I was supposed to use, and never could get it to look right. So back it went.

It was way too big

The wool and fur of this coat were nice, but the size was comically large. Batwing sleeves didn't really help either. Wearing it made me feel like a shapeless blob. Don't get me wrong, I like the oversized trend, but this one really didn't meet expectations!

returned without wearing

I ordered this coat for a trip to Paris thinking a shape that offers room for layers would be great. I headed reviews and ordered the smallest size and man were the reviews understating how big it is. This coat is soooooo labeled I could easily have gotten a 000 if one existed! It was huge everywhere (actually so large it's a joke)-- and it would have been a joke to wear. I think I could have fit another person in this coat with me and closed it no problem. SIZE DOWN at least 2 sizes! Small people stay away.