I love this jacket. Second time renting it. Perfect for New York City winter

Hard to button and a little brown but overall great puffer, very big

Runs large, I ordered my usual size M but could have gone with the small. I'm keeping it anyway because I just love it! Cozy and warm. Interesting tie closure and neck button which keeps the coat nicely closed even on a cold windy day. Olive green which is a nice break from all the black puffers out there.

I've had this for a few weeks and I'm having a hard time returning it. Temperatures just dipped here, so it's a timely rental. It's warmer and far more chic than my practical and utilitarian black puffer.

Super cute coat, definitely runs on the larger side though. Becuase there is no zipper it’s a bit harder to wear it when it’s really cold, even though it’s a very warm coat! Lots of compliments on the look.

Very stylish and lux feeling. I could have ordered down.

was too bulky in the wrong places on me

I didn’t wear it as it looked better on the hanger than on me

It just overwhelmed me....pretty sure I would need to be about 5 inches taller for this to work....very cool, though!

Very boxy that could possibly look good if you only wear it with heels and fitted jeans. Despite not having proper closures (it just has the ring and very long strap thing in the front) it kept me fairly warm in frigid temps. Overall, wouldn't opt for it again since it just looked bad thrown over casual outfits. It does feel big, but I think it's meant to be oversized.

I love the adventurous profile of this coat but ultimately thought the puffy collar effect did not look as good on me as I expected. I only wore once or twice.

Gigantic collar in a face dwarfing way. Not recommended if you're petite or have a small face. The jacket is also large, and the wrap dress way of tying it closed is unwieldy. I think it would be warm though. Didn't test it outside however.

Wanted to love this jacket but I just couldn't figure it out. It's difficult to wrap and wore pretty boxy

I was so excited for this jacket. The material is great, and I love the faux leather look, but it was HUGE. I mean, I was swimming in it. It still had the tags on and I can see why. Definitely size down at least one whole size, it will still probably be boxy if that's the look you're going for.

I'm an extra small so sizing down is not an option. My friend who wears a large was able to fit into the extra small just fine. The asymmetrical bottom and tie closer were just too strange for me. I did like the material. The styling and size just did not work for me.