INVITE FRIENDS|HOW IT WORKS|CHAT WITH A STYLIST|1.800.509.0842

my ACCOUNT ▼

Rentals Profile Credits Invites

| REVIEWS | ♥ | MY BAG

What's New

Dresses

Accessories

Essentials

Designers

Blog

Back to browsing

Butterfly Kisses Dress by Pencey

Butterfly Kisses Dress by Pencey

Butterfly Kisses Dress by Pencey

Butterfly Kisses Dress by Pencey

Pencey

Butterfly Kisses Dress

Rental $60 Retail $375

info

Stylist Notes
Product Details
Size & Fit

Take a twirl in this sexy yet feminine Pencey dress. All your girlfriends will want to copy your flirty style to have that in style Spring look. Shown here with the Lulu Frost's Silver Drift Cuff.

Chat with a fit specialist

Printed silk (100 % silk). V neckline. Ruched bodice with cut-outs. Full skirt. Hook-and-eye closure. Hidden back zip. 35'' from shoulder to hem. Imported.

Chat with a fit specialist

This dress runs slightly large. We recommend going one size down for back-up size (see following fit notes for exceptions). Sized 0-8.

BUST: Works best for A to C cup sizes- cut outs expose upper waist-should be worn with a NuBra or no bra and fashion tape
WAIST: Fitted - full skirt conceals lower abdomen
HIPS: Not fitted - full skirt does not hug hips or backside
LENGTH: Mid-thigh - (on a 5'5" model)

UNDERGARMENTS: Should be worn with a NuBra or no bra and fashion tape; dress has built-in boning in bodice
FABRIC: Fabric has no stretch
GREAT FOR: Apple, Athletic, Hourglass, Pear, Petite, Tall, Straight & Narrow body types
(Model's height is 5'9''.)

Size chart

Chat with a fit specialist

Enter your shipping zip code
Select size

Select free 2nd size

Size & fit notes
Select the day you'd like your dress to arrive

We recommend you select a rental start date 1-2 days before your event.

4 days 8 days ($96)
- Start Date
- Mail Back
- Unavailable
- *No delivery on Sundays

Complete your look

Got A Minute? Share your review (upload a pic, too!) and help others select the perfect style and fit.

Reviews

Average Rating

Overall Fit

Runs small
True to size
Runs large

Customer Photos

Sort by: Featured Newest Rating

Chloe

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 0

Height: 5' 7"

Age: 20

Bust size: 32B

Body type: Straight & narrow

Weight: 118 lbs

Aug 10, 2012

The cute outs made a really cute dress a little sexier

Size worn: 2

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Formal Affair

The dress fit really well. It is way prettier on than on the hanger. I didn't have a problem with my bra showing, just wear a strapless one and you will be fine.

Jen

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 5"

Age: 25

Bust size: 32D

Body type: Full Bust

Weight: 120 lbs

Jun 15, 2013

flirty without being too much for a girl's night

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Party

I wore this as for o a 1920s Great Gatsby viewing party. I thought the dress was great, although I did have to use fashion tape to make sure the top cut out didn't overexpose me. The dress was light and flowy at the bottom and was great to wear!

Christine

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 6

Height: 5' 9"

Age: 25

Bust size: 34C

Body type: Hourglass

Weight: 134 lbs

Jun 10, 2013

Wish I could've had two size options on this one

Size worn: 6

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Wedding

I really loved this dress - especially the fabric and print - but the cutouts just did not sit right on me. I ordered it as my second $25 option (so I didn't have the option to order 2 sizes) for a wedding and ended up wearing it for the rehearsal dinner. I think the 4 would have fit much better for the sake of the cutouts.

Lauren

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 4

Height: 5' 4"

Age: 26

Bust size: 34D

Body type: Hourglass

Weight: 130 lbs

May 29, 2013

Great dress for vacation!

Size worn: 4

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Vacation

I spent the Memorial Day weekend with my husband in DC, and decided on a whim to rent a dress for the day. Loved this one - it was a little chilly on the day I wore it, but it was perfect with a cardigan and pashmina! The cutouts made it where I couldn't wear a bra without it showing, but I felt fully supported (and I'm a 34-D). I could have worn the 4 or the 6, but the 4 provided much more support (in the 6 i was afraid I'd provide a show through the cutouts). Definitely would rent again!

MKP

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 0

Height: 5' 0"

Age: 33

Bust size: 32B

Body type: Petite

Weight: 100 lbs

May 6, 2013

So many compliments!

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Date

Rented this for our date weekend out of town, and complete strangers made a point to come up and compliment me on it! I found it to be a tad larger than most 0's are - but a hidden safety pin at the back was all I needed to make it a tad more snug. I loved renting it!

Jennifer

Usually wears: 6

Height: 5' 7"

Age: 21

Bust size: 34C

Body type: Athletic

Weight: 140 lbs

May 1, 2013

This dress was extremely flattering and I got a lot of compliments!

Size worn: 4

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Formal Affair

The fit was very comfortable and runs a little large. I did try on the size 6, but the straps kept falling off my shoulders. Overall I loved the dress and I wish I didn't have to send it back!

Sarah

Usually wears: 8

Height: 5' 6"

Age: 19

Bust size: 36C

Body type: Athletic

Apr 20, 2013

This dress made me feel GREAT!

Size worn: 6

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Formal Affair

I had been looking at this dress for a long time and I was so happy with my choice! It definitely does run large, even with the right size the cutouts were still loose. I loved the pattern on the dress and it was so comfortable. I would recommend wearing a strapless bra though. Overall, wonderful dress, unforgettable night.

TaTa12

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 6

Height: 5' 8"

Age: 28

Bust size: 34C

Body type: Athletic

Weight: 140 lbs

Apr 18, 2013

Such a FUN dress! The length was great, neckline too, the slits were just a pop of excitement.

Size worn: 6

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Date

Fashion tape is needed unless you don't mind the occassional under-boob pop out. The 4 fit and slits were a little smaller (b/c the waist sat a little higher) ... the 6 waist fell closer to my hips. Simple jewelry was perfect.

meredith

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 4

Height: 5' 9"

Age: 21

Bust size: 32C

Body type: Pear

Weight: 132 lbs

Mar 21, 2013

perfect!

Size worn: 2

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Party

fit like a glove, except under the boobs where the first slit is.... overall it looked great and wasr rally comfortable!

Hayley

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 6"

Age: 22

Body type: Straight & narrow

Jan 20, 2013

I wore this for a senior formal and absolutely loved it!

Size worn: 2

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Formal Affair

Super comfortable and flattering and fits pretty true to size. Such a cute dress!

Shannon

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 6"

Age: 30

Bust size: 34B

Body type: Athletic

Weight: 125 lbs

May 21, 2012

Perfection!

Size worn: 2

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Wedding

I rented this dress for a friends wedding and loved it! This was my first rental from RTR and I am hooked! Not only was the dress beautiful, the fit was phenominal and the reviews from the other gals were extremely helpful! Yes the dress runs large and the side cut outs could show potential "underboobage" but nothing a little fashion tape couldnt fix! Thanks RTR...i will def. spread the word!

Jin

Usually wears: 0

Height: 5' 3"

Age: 21

Bust size: 32C

Body type: Athletic

Weight: 115 lbs

Oct 22, 2012

literally every single person i saw complemented the dress!

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Party

it runs a bit large and the ribbing kept it from laying flat against my ribcage, but the cutouts on the side are perfectly placed and so, so flattering! wore it with a nu bra and didn't have to worry about mishaps all night. loved that it wasn't supershort- kept it on the classy side of sexy. paired it with a dark blue leather jacket and sky high pumps and went from a birthday dinner to a club, then to a house party! this dress fit in perfectly at all three places. i absolutely recommend that you rent it.

Viv

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 6

Height: 5' 5"

Age: 21

Body type: Athletic

Aug 20, 2012

Cute and Sexy

Size worn: 4

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Party

I rented this for a sorority formal and it fit perfectly! The dress itself it super cute and the cutouts give it a little edge, which I loved! The only tricky part was the bra situation. My strapless bra kept sneaking out, but double-sided tape definitely helped!

korrin

Usually wears: 4

Height: 5' 4"

Age: 17

Bust size: 34C

Body type: Straight & narrow

Weight: 125 lbs

Oct 7, 2012

Fall Homecoming

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Party

I wore this dress for my fall homecoming and everyone loved it! I got compliments about every aspect: the cut-outs, color and florals on it. I felt comfortable and beautiful in my dress which to me, is the most important part about a dress!

Lori

Usually wears: 4

Height: 5' 4"

Age: 30

Bust size: 34D

Body type: Hourglass

Weight: 125 lbs

Sep 26, 2012

Loved this dress!!!

Size worn: 2

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Party

I am usually a size 4 in dresses so I rented a size 4 and size 2 since so many of the reviewers have commented on how large it runs. I ended up wearing the size 2 and probably could have gone down to a size 0. The dress was a success and I will definitely use Rent the Runway again:)

Ali

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 4

Height: 5' 1"

Age: 27

Bust size: 32D

Body type: Hourglass

Weight: 135 lbs

Sep 26, 2012

Comfy and Chic

Size worn: 4

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Other

I wore this dress for a friend's bday dinner/night out. It's very comfy, though the dress ran a tad big. RTR as always has great customer service and I actually fell in love with the dress from trying it on at their showroom in NYC.

Rebecca

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 6"

Age: 21

Bust size: 34C

Body type: Hourglass

Weight: 125 lbs

Sep 19, 2012

I got so many compliments and the cut-outs made it cute and sexy but not over-the-top!

Size worn: 2

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Formal Affair

Great fit! I got the four just in case but the smaller size was better- I didn't have to worry about falling out- which is good since I had to go sans bra! I'm about 34C so I was concerned about that but didn't have any problems with the girls ;)

Amanda

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 4

Height: 5' 6"

Age: 24

Bust size: 32B

Body type: Pear

Weight: 130 lbs

Sep 8, 2012

Average rental

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Party

Really cute dress but runs REALLY large. I usually wear a 4-6, (more on the 4 end 6 only for butt-hugging dresses) and I got a 0 and it was still a little big! I managed to make it work with some dress tape in places, but without it the dress would buckle out at the neck and the waist band on the sides drooped. I was cute and I got compliments, but not the best fit... especially if you're any smaller than me. (34'-25-38' last time I checked)

Alicia

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 4

Height: 5' 2"

Age: 22

Bust size: 34D

Body type: Full Bust

Weight: 130 lbs

Aug 28, 2012

I've never been told so many times how LITTLE I looked! This made me feel amazing.

Size worn: 2

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Party

I love to dress up, and this is the perfect dress to rent if you're looking to try cut-outs. I don't usually wear tight dresses with cut-outs so this was a perfect balance in between scandalous and tight on the top, with an A-line skirt that was very flattering.

Kate

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 4

Height: 5' 2"

Age: 30

Bust size: 32B

Body type: Hourglass

Aug 22, 2012

I received a ton of compliments.

Size worn: 2

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Wedding

I rented this for a bridal shower. I am typically a 4 or a 6 but i read the reviews and orders a 4 and a 2. They only sent the 2 but it worked out because it fit great.

Chandler

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 0

Height: 5' 3"

Age: 20

Body type: Petite

Weight: 115 lbs

Aug 10, 2012

Feeling confident in a great dress made me feel confident to bet on my favorite horses at the horse races!

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Other

This dress is such a cute day time look. It was perfect for a sunny day at the horse races! The sides were loose but I don't think they were made to be skin tight. I definitely found it well fitting.

Nicole

Usually wears: 6

Height: 5' 8"

Age: 30

Bust size: 34C

Body type: Hourglass

Weight: 132 lbs

Jun 17, 2012

I was told by a complete stranger that it was the best dress of the night!

Size worn: 4

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Wedding

I rented this dress for an outdoor, spring wedding in the Vermont mountains. I received a large number of compliments from my husband, friends, and strangers! I felt really great in it. The mix of the feminine design and skirt complemented well with the sexier cutouts. As the other reviews mention, the dress runs large. I went with my backup size which was a size lower than what I typically wear. My only issue with the dress is that the size of cutouts were larger than they appear in the picture. After a bit of trial and error, I was able to make the dress work. You absolutely need double-sided tape. I often can get away without wearing a bra with dresses and sometimes shirts, but this dress you need the support as to avoid any unwanted popouts or side-boob! Had I not needed to spend quite some time working out the fit, I would have given it 5 stars.

Kourtney

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 0

Height: 5' 3"

Age: 35

Bust size: 32C

Body type: Athletic

Weight: 114 lbs

May 17, 2013

Although the concept is a cute one......

Size worn: None

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Other

.....this dress was too large so I had to send it back and didn't wear it.

Dana

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 2"

Age: 39

Bust size: 32C

Body type: Hourglass

Weight: 120 lbs

Apr 10, 2013

Overall, not what I envisioned.

Size worn: 2

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Vacation

This dress looked better on the hanger than it did on me! The quality was not runway worthy; I thought it was going to be flirty, but it was just flimsy. Although I am petite, I do have curves and a chest, and the cut outs made me self conscious. This is better for someone who is taller and not so curvy. I could have dealt with it on a vacation, but I couldn't get over the quality of material to make it work.

Jennifer

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 0"

Age: 48

Body type: Athletic

Mar 3, 2013

We did not wear the dress as it was not appropriate for the occasion.

Size worn: None

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Formal Affair

DId not wear it. Fit true to size.

karina

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 0"

Age: 23

Bust size: 34D

Body type: Petite

Weight: 107 lbs

Feb 16, 2013

The dress is even more beautiful in person, but runs large.

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Other

I was so excited when I saw this dress in person but when i tried it on it was much too loose and unfortunately for me i already had the smallest size. I do recommend it though very beautiful, pictures dont do it justice.

Madison

Usually wears: 4

Height: 5' 9"

Age: 18

Bust size: 34A

Body type: Pear

Weight: 135 lbs

Feb 15, 2013

SUCH a great dress. I got so many compliments.

Size worn: 4

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Formal Affair

We had to pin the sides in a bit to make it fit better. Still worked out fabulously. Love this dress! btw im 5'11 and wear a 2-4. this dress was the perfect length. Not too short!!

Meredith

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 5"

Age: 18

Bust size: 34B

Body type: Hourglass

Weight: 130 lbs

Jan 23, 2013

LOVED IT.

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Formal Affair

Only problem I had with the dress was the slits along the sides. But with a little fashion tape it worked out very nicely, got a lot of compliments on it! THanks!

Kim P

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 6

Height: 4' 11"

Age: 34

Bust size: 34D

Body type: Petite

Weight: 125 lbs

Jan 8, 2013

Great dress

Size worn: 4

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Party

It fit really great and was very comfortable. The back was really sexy but still trendy enough to wear to a work fundraiser/function.

Amanda

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 0

Height: 5' 3"

Age: 27

Bust size: 32B

Body type: Petite

Weight: 112 lbs

Nov 16, 2012

A perfect party or weekend dress!

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Party

The look of this dress is adorable, however it ran a bit big on top for me. I'm pretty small on top, so if you are too, I'd definitely wear a push-up bra or something like that. The dress may also show some bra, but it's not too big of a deal. All in all, it was very cute!

Kelly

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 0

Height: 5' 4"

Age: 22

Bust size: 34A

Body type: Petite

Weight: 115 lbs

Nov 12, 2012

Wore this dress as I ran a RTR Trunk Show on my campus and it was HUGE hit!!!!!

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Other

The dress ran big in the torso area. It was still wearable and it looked great on! Got a lot of compliments. I would definitely suggest getting this dress a size down and if you are a 0 like myself be ready that you may have to tuck or pin in certain areas.

Cameron

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 6

Height: 5' 3"

Age: 26

Body type: Hourglass

Oct 10, 2012

Favorite dress I've ever worn!

Size worn: 4

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Formal Affair

The cutouts aren't too scandalous at all and didn't squeeze. I've never worn cutouts so I was worried, but this dress was amazing and I felt confident in it! Perfect length for us shorter girls!!!

Rachel

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 6"

Age: 23

Bust size: 34C

Body type: Straight & narrow

Weight: 120 lbs

Oct 2, 2012

This Dress was perfect!

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Party

Just was I was looking for, for a fun Saturaday night event. I got a number of compliments on the dress and people loved the fun cutouts on the side.

Kris

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 2"

Age: 27

Bust size: 34C

Body type: Athletic

Weight: 118 lbs

Oct 1, 2012

This dress is perfect for a date night! Cute, romantic, and the cut-outs make it sexy!

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Date

I wore this dress for a date night because I was sick of my same-old outfits. It was perfect. The floral pattern make it romantic and feminine and the cut outs are a nice surprise that throw in a little bit of sexiness. I wore it with a bright yellow short-sleeved cardigan when it got cold at night. I'd recommend for anyone who wants to play up their feminine side for a nice date or brunch. Only thing I'd say that was a bit frustrating was that the bodice/top part of the dress was a little roomy...

Patricia

Usually wears: 4

Height: 5' 7"

Age: 18

Body type: Athletic

Sep 23, 2012

Cute and a good fit!

Size worn: 2

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Party

I ordered the 4 and the 2 but the 2 fit perfectly, so size down. The length was perfect for me and worked on top with the side cut-outs, I didn't have to worry about it at all the entire night!

Michelle

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 4

Height: 6' 0"

Age: 37

Bust size: 36C

Body type: Athletic

Weight: 135 lbs

Sep 21, 2012

Loved it!

Size worn: 4

Overall fit: True to Size

Rented for: Date

This dress was sweet and sexy all in one! I was nervous about the cut outs and an accidental wardrobe slip, but all went well. I'm tall so I wore the 4 to make it long enough...the 2 was way too short. Very fun dress :)

Christina

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 0

Height: 5' 3"

Age: 33

Bust size: 32A

Body type: Petite

Weight: 108 lbs

Sep 17, 2012

Cute dress but didn't work for me

Size worn: 0

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Party

I love the pattern and the style but unfortunately it was too big on me. I am very petite and the 0 was huge on me. I think the dress would work for those with a larger chest because I just couldn't fill it out! Very disappointed since I didn't have a back-up for the occasion I ordered it for.

Sydney

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 8"

Age: 24

Bust size: 34A

Body type: Athletic

Weight: 130 lbs

Sep 17, 2012

Too baggy...

Size worn: None

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Wedding

I just wish this had not been so baggy on me!! I really liked the dress and thought it was fun but the slits on the side were gaping open and I would not have been able to comfortably wear the dress the whole night. Also the skirt was very full and seemed like too much fabric so it was not very flattering.

Genevieve

Top Contributor

Usually wears: 2

Height: 5' 5"

Age: 27

Bust size: 34B

Body type: Pear

Weight: 135 lbs

Sep 11, 2012

Adorable but runs big

Size worn: 2

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Other

I normally wear between size 0-4 depending on the type of dress. I rented a 2 since it runs big, but I definitely could have used a 0.

Lee

Usually wears: 6

Height: 5' 4"

Age: 28

Bust size: 32D

Body type: Athletic

Weight: 140 lbs

Aug 30, 2012

Cute but YES SIZE DOWN

Size worn: 6

Overall fit: Large

Rented for: Wedding

Beautiful fabric (more navy blue). Had rented another dress so ended up wearing that one instead. Other users suggest you should go down a size, they are correct. I am normally a 6 and should have gotten a 4. Would have given this a higher score had it worked.

See more reviews:

Next