Name: Out of Your League Dress
Brand: Jay Godfrey
SKU: JG12
Price: 50 USD
Availability: OutOfStock
Rating: 4.0 (49 reviews)

Very cute dress - a little loose on top but no big deal - was never uncomfortable.  My husband is the one who talked me into renting this dress for his birthday and so I wore it for him.
Danced all night in it and was comfortable.  The belt is completely separate - and I was thinking of going without it - but in my opinion the dress looks much better with the belt than without one.  I would have gone maybe with a solid black belt, but I didn't have one. 

This dress was perfect for my birthday party. Its just the right amount of sass and class. Note to potential renters: This is a short dress. I am only 5ft and it still hit above my mid thigh. It was also a little big on top, but nothing a little bit of fashion tape couldn't fix. I loved it! Thank you!

Got tons of compliments. Very comfy and cute. Also flattering!

I am usually between a 2 and a 4; I wore the 2 and it was still quite baggy in the chest (I'm a 34B). It's a pretty dress, but the fit just wasn't right. I didn't feel super confident in this dress.

The dress looks exactly like in the photos, except that the green is a lil brighter. I usually wear size 4 and that's the size I ended up wearing, dress was a lil big on the chest area for me but fitting as an overall was good. I loved the contrast of the white belt and the length of the dress, it's short as I wanted it. I would totally recommend this dress for a party.




It was a bit tight around the bust and the waist but overall incredibly comfortable. I tried it with a couple of other belts but the one it came with worked best. 

Great dress!! It is pretty short so I had to be cautious not to lean forward. Other than that, the fit was good and I felt great in it!!

I wore this out for dinner & drinks on my birthday.  I ordered the 6 and 8, and ended up wearing the 6.  The 6 was a little shorter than I am usually comfortable with, but since I was wearing black tights and the top fit my small chest much better than the 8, I went with the 6.  It was flattering and comfortable, and I got lots of compliments.  Four stars instead of five because I don't think it's absolutely the most best fitting style for a short girl like me (my torso is probably a little too short), but I enjoyed it.

This was a fun dress I wore to my cousin's engagement party. I got so many compliments the whole night. I would recommend it!

I wore this dress for my bachelorette party in Chicago...I could not have been happier with it!!! So gorgeous!!! I wore a size 6, and I was surprised to find the top was a little big (which is shocking since I am pretty busty up top).  I also wasn't a huge fan of the belt that the dress came with, so I added my own!  I could not have been happier! I would highly recommend this cute little number any day!

I wore this dress for my husband's holiday work party - figured it was conservative enough while still being interesting and flattering.  I'm petite and the dress felt short, but I think that was more due to the A-line bottom than the actual length.  The white belt is perfect - it makes the dress look complete while also being functional and alllowing you to cinch in the waist/make the dress fit even better.  The dress made it through a rainstorm on the way to the party and still looked fine for the rest of the night...wish I could say the same for my hair!  

This dress was more than I expected. It does a little large if you have a small chest. My only complaint was that the side of the dress without the strap kept falling down. It was a minor annoyance. With my height the dress was short, but not inappropriate. Had to be careful when I sat down! I would definitely rent this again for a more casual event where I wanted to stand out.

This is certainly a pretty dress, but the look was NOT cute on me, due to some very awkward stitching in the bust. I rented it for my husband's work party and, turns out, it was NSFW! I tried maneuvering the dress, wearing a different bra, smoothing out the crease -- nothing worked. So, sadly, I couldn't wear it. Love RTR, though, as I got a refund on the dress and the purse that I had rented to match it. I didn't check the size 0 to see if it had the same problem, but the picture shows me in the size 2. Weird nip aside, I probably would have gotten a 2 and a 4 if I were ordering again. Was a tad tight.

it is short, so very self-conscious while dancing with my daughters, but very comfortable to wear!

I'm a teacher and I wore this to chaperone a cruise around Manhattan with the senior class.  I thought this dress was an appropriate length with just a little bit of trendy to it.  It was a hit with the seniors and the other chaperones and none of the administrators had an issue with the bare shoulder.  I also coach softball at the school so I loved the little belt.  It looked like a cute little play on the stitches of a softball.  Fit great.  Great color. Totally comfortable and not too short on me.

The black material is a little clingy. The belt was the perfect addition to the dress! It is shorter than I expected.

This was 1 of 2 dresses for my 1st RTR experience for a bach party w/e.  Got a TON of compliments on this dress, and the bow (that at first I didn't think I was going to like) ended up looking really cute once I saw it on! The dress is super comfy, especially for a night of drinking (in other words, won't see a bloated beer belly b/c of the a-line :-)  Great dress!

I rented this for my dad's wedding rehearsal dinner and it was a hit! I wore a strapless bra with it and it fit perfectly. It's a great dress that is a perfect combination between classy and cute/trendy.

I wore this dress to a wedding and I got a lot of compliments on it. It is not as short as it appears in the picture, so it was definitely wedding appropriate. The green was not as vibrant as in the photo and the strings that hold up the dress on hangers kept slipping out, which was pretty annoying. I would recommend taping the strings. Other than that, it was pretty!

I rented this dress for a trip to Atlanta to see my boyfriend. This was my first rental from rtr and it was great. I also rented the necklace that is recommended and I have to say that it really made the dress!The overall fit of the dress was great, although the top was a little big. Overall I got compliments on my dress and I didn't want to take it off! 

I wore this dress for my bachelorette party on St. Patrick's Day.  I loved it!   The fit was great, although it was a little short (I am 5'9" but was wearing 4" heels).  I probably would not have worn it for anything other than a bachelorette party because of the length.   It was perfect for the night though and I received several compliments!  All of my bridesmaids and even strangers now know about RTR!  

Dress fit really well.  Definitely on the short side, a bit shorter than I expected.  But it got a ton of compliments.  Necklace looked amazing with it.

Out of Your League Dress

Jay Godfrey

Reviews

Runs True to Size

Product Details

Materials and Measurements

Size and Fit

Your Bag